Translation of soundscape perceptual attributes from English to Turkish

被引:15
|
作者
Yorukoglu, P. N. Dokmeci [1 ]
Bayrak, O. Turker [2 ]
Coban, N. Akbulut [3 ]
Osma, U. B. Ercakmak [1 ]
Aletta, F. [4 ]
Oberman, T. [4 ]
Mitchell, A. [4 ]
Kang, J. [4 ]
机构
[1] Cankaya Univ, Fac Architecture, Dept Interior Architecture, Ankara, Turkiye
[2] Cankaya Univ, Intercurricular Courses Dept, Stat Unit, Ankara, Turkiye
[3] Antalya Prov Directorate Environm Urbanizat & Cli, Dept Environm Management & Audit, Antalya, Turkiye
[4] UCL, Inst Environm Design & Engn, Bartlett, Cent House, London WC1H 0NN, England
基金
欧洲研究理事会;
关键词
ISO; 12913; Acoustics; Soundscape; Perceived affective quality; Listening tests; Reliability; Context validity; Conceptual equivalence; Turkish; SAMPLE-SIZE REQUIREMENTS; INTRACLASS CORRELATIONS; PARK;
D O I
10.1016/j.apacoust.2023.109391
中图分类号
O42 [声学];
学科分类号
070206 ; 082403 ;
摘要
The International Standard Organization (ISO) published the standard series on soundscape for the identification, data collection and data analysis. However, since all these standards are in English language, the reliable standardized usage in other languages and its applicability is questionable. Thus, this two-staged study aims: i) to determine the Turkish equivalences of the 8 soundscape perceptual attributes that are published in ISO/TS 12913-2:2018 and ISO/TS 12913-3:2019, ii) to analyze if the determined Turkish attributes have concept equivalence to the original ones, and iii) to determine if the translated Turkish scale is reproducible. The first stage involved the translation of the attributes by focus group discussions and finalization by Turkish linguistic experts. As a result, the attributes 'eventful', 'vibrant', 'pleasant', 'calm', 'uneventful', 'monotonous', 'annoying', and 'chaotic' are translated to Turkish as 'hareketli', 'coskulu', 'keyifli', 'sakin', 'duragan', 'tekduze', 'rahatsiz edici', and 'karmasik', respectively. The second stage involves the analysis of reproducibility in terms of inter-rater reliability and conceptual validity. It is found that the Turkish scale is reproducible based on high inter-rater reliability in all attri-butes. Context validity at a conceptual level is analyzed both in terms of the difference between the aver-age scores given to the English attributes and their corresponding Turkish equivalences and the correlation between the English and Turkish scores given to each attribute. The highest difference between the average scores (around 10 points on a slider scale of 0 to 100) is found to be in the translation of 'vibrant' while the lowest correlated one (slightly lower than 0.5) is found in 'chaotic' attribute as in line with literature. Despite this result, when the scores are reduced to 2 dimensions as pleasantness and eventfulness, it is seen that there is a high correlation between the English and Turkish scales. It is considered that the results obtained from this research could act as a base in the future for the establishment of Turkish Standards on soundscape and standardization of the translated and validated Turkish soundscape perceptual attributes and the 'perceived affective quality' scale defined under ISO/TS 12913-2:2018 in English. (c) 2023 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
引用
收藏
页数:12
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [1] Quantitative evaluation approach for English-Catalan translation of soundscape perceptual attributes
    Freixes, Marc
    Orga, Ferran
    Alsina-Pages, Rosa Ma
    APPLIED ACOUSTICS, 2025, 227
  • [2] Quantitative evaluation approach for translation of perceptual soundscape attributes: Initial application to the Thai Language
    Watcharasupat, Karn N.
    Jaratjarungkiat, Sureenate
    Lam, Bhan
    Jitwiriyanont, Sujinat
    Ooi, Kenneth
    Ong, Zhen-Ting
    Pichetpan, Nitipong
    Akaratham, Kanyanut
    Suthiwan, Titima
    Rojtinnakorn, Monthita
    Gan, Woon-Seng
    APPLIED ACOUSTICS, 2022, 200
  • [3] Quantitative evaluation approach for translation of perceptual soundscape attributes: Initial application to the Thai Language
    Watcharasupat, Karn N.
    Jaratjarungkiat, Sureenate
    Lam, Bhan
    Jitwiriyanont, Sujinat
    Ooi, Kenneth
    Ong, Zhen-Ting
    Pichetpan, Nitipong
    Akaratham, Kanyanut
    Suthiwan, Titima
    Rojtinnakorn, Monthita
    Gan, Woon-Seng
    Applied Acoustics, 2022, 200
  • [4] Translation and cross-cultural adaptation methodology for soundscape attributes - A study with independent translation groups from English to Greek
    Papadakis, Nikolaos M.
    Aletta, Francesco
    Kang, Jian
    Oberman, Tin
    Mitchell, Andrew
    Stavroulakis, Georgios E.
    APPLIED ACOUSTICS, 2022, 200
  • [5] Soundscape attributes translation: Current projects and challenges
    Aletta, Francesco
    Astolfi, Arianna
    Kang, Jian
    Oberman, Tin
    Mitchell, Andrew
    APPLIED ACOUSTICS, 2025, 228
  • [6] Translating perceived affective quality attributes of soundscape from English into Korean
    Kim, Tae-Hui
    Kim, Geon-Hee
    Hong, Joo-Young
    APPLIED ACOUSTICS, 2024, 222
  • [7] Creating a common language for soundscape research: Translation and validation of Dutch soundscape attributes
    van den Bosch, Kirsten A.
    Fitzpatrick, Darragh W.
    Luhr, Tamara C.
    Orlik, Nicolas B.
    Sarampalis, Anastatios
    APPLIED ACOUSTICS, 2023, 212
  • [8] A European and Brazilian cross-national investigation into the Portuguese translation of soundscape perceptual attributes within the SATP project
    Antunes, Sonia Monteiro
    Michalski, Ranny Loureiro Xavier Nascimento
    Carvalho, Maria Luiza de Ulhoa
    Alves, Sonia
    Ribeiro, Luis Claudio
    APPLIED ACOUSTICS, 2023, 211
  • [9] Evaluating soundscape in the Italian language: Validation of the translation of the English standardized perceptual attributes of the ISO/TS 12913-2:2018 and comparison with other Romance languages
    Puglisi, Giuseppina Emma
    Shtrepi, Louena
    Masoero, Marco Carlo
    Astolfi, Arianna
    APPLIED ACOUSTICS, 2024, 222
  • [10] Converging towards a French translation of soundscape attributes: Insights from Quebec and France
    Tarlao, Cynthia
    Aumond, Pierre
    Lavandier, Catherine
    Guastavino, Catherine
    APPLIED ACOUSTICS, 2023, 211