Comparison of Long-Wave and Mid-Wave Infrared Imaging Modalities for Photothermal Coherence Tomography of Human Teeth

The ability to detect dental caries at early stages lies at the heart of minimal intervention dentistry, enabling the curing or arresting of carious lesions before they advance to the cavity stage. Enhanced truncated-correlation photothermal coherence tomography (eTC-PCT) using mid-wave infrared (MWIR) cameras has recently been shown to offer tomographic visualization of early caries. The tomographic slicing ability of such systems, however, is believed to be limited by direct radiative thermal emission through the translucent dental enamel in the 3-5 mu m MWIR spectral range. Such radiative emissions can dominate the delayed conductive thermal contributions needed for tomographic reconstruction of internal dental defects. It has been hypothesized that long-wave infrared (LWIR) eTC-PCT systems may offer better tomographic performance by taking advantage of the intrinsic attenuation of direct radiative emission by dental enamel in the LWIR spectral range, enabling more effective delayed conductive thermal contributions from subsurface caries. More than an order of magnitude lower cost of the system is another key attribute of LWIR eTC-PCT which can open the door for downstream translation of the technology to clinics. In this report, we offer a systematic comparison of the performance/effectiveness of caries detection with LWIR and MWIR eTC-PCT systems for detecting natural caries, bacterial caries, and artificially demineralized enamel surfaces. Our results suggest that the low-cost LWIR based eTC-PCT system provides 3D visualization and 2D slice-by-slice images of early caries and internal micro-cracks similar to those obtained from the more expensive MWIR-based eTC-PCT system, albeit with similar to 1.3dB lower signal-to-noise ratio.