Why does duress undermine consent?

被引:9
|
作者
Dougherty, Tom [1 ]
机构
[1] Univ N Carolina, Dept Philosophy, 240 E Cameron Ave, Chapel Hill, NC 27515 USA
来源
NOUS | 2021年 / 55卷 / 02期
关键词
Coercion; Consent; Duress; Valid;
D O I
10.1111/nous.12313
中图分类号
B [哲学、宗教];
学科分类号
01 ; 0101 ;
摘要
In this essay, I discuss why consent is invalidated by duress that involves attaching penalties to someone's refusal to give consent. At the heart of my explanation is the Complaint Principle. This principle specifies that consent is defeasibly invalid when the consent results from someone conditionally imposing a penalty on the consent-giver's refusal to give the consent, such that the consent-giver has a legitimate complaint against this imposition focused on how it is affects their incentives for consenting. The Complaint Principle says that this consent is defeasibly invalid to make room for the Authorization Principle, which allows sincere authorizations to constitute valid consent, even when these are issued by an agent acting under duress. The Authorization Principle has application only in cases of third-party duress because when the consent-receiver is the source of the duress, the consent-giver is not sincerely authorizing the action.
引用
收藏
页码:317 / 333
页数:17
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [31] Does the Mathematical Nature of Physics Undermine Physicalism?
    Schneider, Susan
    JOURNAL OF CONSCIOUSNESS STUDIES, 2017, 24 (9-10) : 7 - 39
  • [32] Acute hunger does not always undermine prosociality
    Haeusser, Jan A.
    Stahlecker, Christina
    Mojzisch, Andreas
    Leder, Johannes
    Van Lange, Paul A. M.
    Faber, Nadira S.
    NATURE COMMUNICATIONS, 2019, 10 (1)
  • [33] INFORMED CONSENT - WHY BOTHER
    BROWNSETT, PM
    SHARMA, P
    MEDICAL EDUCATION, 1990, 24 (02) : 206 - 206
  • [34] Confabulation does not undermine introspection for propositional attitudes
    Andreotta, Adam J.
    SYNTHESE, 2021, 198 (05) : 4851 - 4872
  • [35] Acute hunger does not always undermine prosociality
    Jan A. Häusser
    Christina Stahlecker
    Andreas Mojzisch
    Johannes Leder
    Paul A. M. Van Lange
    Nadira S. Faber
    Nature Communications, 10
  • [36] Does Unconscious Reward Undermine Intrinsic Motivation?
    Ichimura, Kenshiro
    Fujino, Masahiro
    Okada, Akiho
    Kobatake, Junichi
    Kusumi, Takashi
    INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF PSYCHOLOGY, 2016, 51 : 189 - 189
  • [37] Why study informed consent?
    Slovenko, R
    HASTINGS CENTER REPORT, 1999, 29 (04) : 4 - 4
  • [38] WHY BOTHER WITH INFORMED CONSENT
    FOSTER, HW
    JOURNAL OF MEDICAL EDUCATION, 1978, 53 (02): : 154 - 155
  • [39] Does immigration undermine welfare state support?
    Bay, Ann-Helen
    Hellevik, Ottar
    Hellevik, Tale
    TIDSSKRIFT FOR SAMFUNNSFORSKNING, 2007, 48 (03): : 377 - 408
  • [40] Does authentic assessment undermine authentic learning?
    Hatala, Rose
    Ellaway, Rachel H.
    ADVANCES IN HEALTH SCIENCES EDUCATION, 2024, 29 (04) : 1067 - 1070