Why does duress undermine consent?

被引:9
|
作者
Dougherty, Tom [1 ]
机构
[1] Univ N Carolina, Dept Philosophy, 240 E Cameron Ave, Chapel Hill, NC 27515 USA
来源
NOUS | 2021年 / 55卷 / 02期
关键词
Coercion; Consent; Duress; Valid;
D O I
10.1111/nous.12313
中图分类号
B [哲学、宗教];
学科分类号
01 ; 0101 ;
摘要
In this essay, I discuss why consent is invalidated by duress that involves attaching penalties to someone's refusal to give consent. At the heart of my explanation is the Complaint Principle. This principle specifies that consent is defeasibly invalid when the consent results from someone conditionally imposing a penalty on the consent-giver's refusal to give the consent, such that the consent-giver has a legitimate complaint against this imposition focused on how it is affects their incentives for consenting. The Complaint Principle says that this consent is defeasibly invalid to make room for the Authorization Principle, which allows sincere authorizations to constitute valid consent, even when these are issued by an agent acting under duress. The Authorization Principle has application only in cases of third-party duress because when the consent-receiver is the source of the duress, the consent-giver is not sincerely authorizing the action.
引用
收藏
页码:317 / 333
页数:17
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [21] Does Neuroscience Undermine Deontological Theory?
    Dean, Richard
    NEUROETHICS, 2010, 3 (01) : 43 - 60
  • [22] How and why does the mode of data collection affect consent to data linkage?
    Jackle, Annette
    Burton, Jonathan
    Couper, Mick P.
    Crossley, Thomas F.
    Walzenbach, Sandra
    SURVEY RESEARCH METHODS, 2022, 16 (03): : 387 - 408
  • [23] Why member portraits can undermine participation
    Cress, Ulrike
    CSCL 2005: COMPUTER SUPPORTED COLLABORATIVE LEARNING 2005: THE NEXT 10 YEARS, PROCEEDINGS, 2005, : 86 - 90
  • [24] Why is Coerced Consent Worse Than No Consent and Deceived Consent?
    Wendler, David
    Wertheimer, Alan
    JOURNAL OF MEDICINE AND PHILOSOPHY, 2017, 42 (02): : 114 - 131
  • [25] Does altruism undermine existence value?
    McConnell, KE
    JOURNAL OF ENVIRONMENTAL ECONOMICS AND MANAGEMENT, 1997, 32 (01) : 22 - 37
  • [26] Does Neuroscience Undermine Deontological Theory?
    Richard Dean
    Neuroethics, 2010, 3 : 43 - 60
  • [27] When does centralization undermine adaptation?
    Liu, Shuo
    Migrow, Dimitri
    JOURNAL OF ECONOMIC THEORY, 2022, 205
  • [28] Does Opacity Undermine Privileged Access?
    Allen, Timothy
    INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF PHILOSOPHICAL STUDIES, 2014, 22 (04) : 617 - 629
  • [29] Does corruption undermine tourism development in Africa?
    Xu, Chenghong
    Yang, Yang
    Dossou, Toyo Amegnonna Marcel
    Berhe, Mesfin Welderufael
    Kambaye, Emmanuelle Ndomandji
    CURRENT ISSUES IN TOURISM, 2023, 26 (11) : 1779 - 1796
  • [30] Does the heterogeneity of autism undermine the neurodiversity paradigm?
    Morley, Georgina
    Bradbury-Jones, Caroline
    Ives, Jonathan
    BIOETHICS, 2021, 35 (01) : 61 - 71