A Standing Asymmetry between Blame and Forgiveness

被引:8
|
作者
Fritz, Kyle G.
Miller, Daniel J.
机构
[1] Department of Public Policy Leadership, University of Mississippi
关键词
HYPOCRITICAL BLAME; AUTHORITY; RESPECT;
D O I
10.1086/719511
中图分类号
B82 [伦理学(道德学)];
学科分类号
摘要
Sometimes it is not one's place to blame or forgive. This phenomenon is captured under the philosophical notion of standing. However, there is an asymmetry to be explained here. One can successfully blame, even if one lacks the standing to do so. Yet, one cannot successfully forgive if one lacks the standing to do so. In this article we explain this asymmetry. We argue that a complete explanation depends on not only a difference in the natures of the standing to blame and forgive but also a difference in the natures of blame and forgiveness themselves.
引用
收藏
页码:759 / 786
页数:28
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [41] Attributions of blame and forgiveness in romantic relationships: A policy-capturing study
    Boon, SD
    Sulsky, LM
    JOURNAL OF SOCIAL BEHAVIOR AND PERSONALITY, 1997, 12 (01): : 19 - 44
  • [42] William Holman Hunt's The 'Scapegoat': Rite of forgiveness, transference of blame
    Boime, A
    ART BULLETIN, 2002, 84 (01): : 94 - 114
  • [43] Hypocrisy, Standing to Blame and Second-Personal Authority
    Piovarchy, Adam
    PACIFIC PHILOSOPHICAL QUARTERLY, 2020, 101 (04) : 603 - 627
  • [44] When Hypocrisy Undermines the Standing to Blame: a Response to Rossi
    Fritz, Kyle G.
    Miller, Daniel J.
    ETHICAL THEORY AND MORAL PRACTICE, 2019, 22 (02) : 379 - 384
  • [45] When Hypocrisy Undermines the Standing to Blame: a Response to Rossi
    Kyle G. Fritz
    Daniel J. Miller
    Ethical Theory and Moral Practice, 2019, 22 : 379 - 384
  • [46] What About the Victim? Neglected Dimensions of the Standing to Blame
    Alexander Edlich
    The Journal of Ethics, 2022, 26 : 209 - 228
  • [47] What About the Victim? Neglected Dimensions of the Standing to Blame
    Edlich, Alexander
    JOURNAL OF ETHICS, 2022, 26 (02): : 209 - 228
  • [48] Generative AI entails a credit-blame asymmetry
    Porsdam Mann, Sebastian
    Earp, Brian D.
    Nyholm, Sven
    Danaher, John
    Moller, Nikolaj
    Bowman-Smart, Hilary
    Hatherley, Joshua
    Koplin, Julian
    Plozza, Monika
    Rodger, Daniel
    Treit, Peter V.
    Renard, Gregory
    McMillan, John
    Savulescu, Julian
    NATURE MACHINE INTELLIGENCE, 2023, 5 (05) : 472 - 475
  • [49] A Duty not to Remain Silent: Hypocrisy and the Lack of Standing not to Blame
    Lippert-Rasmussen, Kasper
    PHILOSOPHICAL QUARTERLY, 2023, 73 (04): : 933 - 949
  • [50] Who to Blame? Learning and Control Strategies with Information Asymmetry
    Liu, Changliu
    Zhang, Wenlong
    Tomizuka, Masayoshi
    2016 AMERICAN CONTROL CONFERENCE (ACC), 2016, : 4859 - 4864