A Standing Asymmetry between Blame and Forgiveness

被引:8
|
作者
Fritz, Kyle G.
Miller, Daniel J.
机构
[1] Department of Public Policy Leadership, University of Mississippi
关键词
HYPOCRITICAL BLAME; AUTHORITY; RESPECT;
D O I
10.1086/719511
中图分类号
B82 [伦理学(道德学)];
学科分类号
摘要
Sometimes it is not one's place to blame or forgive. This phenomenon is captured under the philosophical notion of standing. However, there is an asymmetry to be explained here. One can successfully blame, even if one lacks the standing to do so. Yet, one cannot successfully forgive if one lacks the standing to do so. In this article we explain this asymmetry. We argue that a complete explanation depends on not only a difference in the natures of the standing to blame and forgive but also a difference in the natures of blame and forgiveness themselves.
引用
收藏
页码:759 / 786
页数:28
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [31] Who Can Blame Whom? Moral Standing to Blame and Punish Deprived Citizens
    Gustavo A. Beade
    Criminal Law and Philosophy, 2019, 13 : 271 - 281
  • [32] Who Can Blame Whom? Moral Standing to Blame and Punish Deprived Citizens
    Beade, Gustavo A.
    CRIMINAL LAW AND PHILOSOPHY, 2019, 13 (02) : 271 - 281
  • [33] The Relationship Between Bilateral Contour Asymmetry in the Human Body in Standing and Walking
    Huelster, Laura J.
    RESEARCH QUARTERLY, 1953, 24 (01): : 44 - 55
  • [34] The morality of action: The asymmetry between judgments of praise and blame in the action-omission effect
    Bostyn, Dries H.
    Roets, Arne
    JOURNAL OF EXPERIMENTAL SOCIAL PSYCHOLOGY, 2016, 63 : 19 - 25
  • [35] Why Does Possessing Standing to Blame Matter?
    Yaure, Philip
    CANADIAN JOURNAL OF PHILOSOPHY, 2025,
  • [36] BLAME, MORAL STANDING AND THE LEGITIMACY OF THE CRIMINAL TRIAL
    Duff, R. A.
    RATIO, 2010, 23 (02) : 123 - 140
  • [37] The Standing To Blame, or Why Moral Disapproval Is What It Is
    Riedener, Stefan
    DIALECTICA, 2019, 73 (1-2) : 183 - 210
  • [38] DOES GOD HAVE THE MORAL STANDING TO BLAME?
    Todd, Patrick
    FAITH AND PHILOSOPHY, 2018, 35 (01) : 33 - 55
  • [39] INTENTIONAL ACTION AND THE PRAISE-BLAME ASYMMETRY
    Hindriks, Frank
    PHILOSOPHICAL QUARTERLY, 2008, 58 (233): : 630 - 641
  • [40] Generative AI entails a credit–blame asymmetry
    Sebastian Porsdam Mann
    Brian D. Earp
    Sven Nyholm
    John Danaher
    Nikolaj Møller
    Hilary Bowman-Smart
    Joshua Hatherley
    Julian Koplin
    Monika Plozza
    Daniel Rodger
    Peter V. Treit
    Gregory Renard
    John McMillan
    Julian Savulescu
    Nature Machine Intelligence, 2023, 5 : 472 - 475