Incomplete Screw Thread Engagement of Proximal Fragment: A Possible Failure Risk After Internal Fixation for Femoral Neck Fractures

Background For successful internal fixation for femoral neck fracture, the sliding mechanism of the screw is important because it can induce inter-fragmental compression. The thread should penetrate the fracture line and be located within the proximal fragment. If screw thread engagement is incomplete and a part of the thread remains within the distal fragment, the screw sliding can be disturbed, potentially leading to fixation failure. We hypothesized that screw thread in the fracture is a risk of fixation failure. Methods We studied 133 hips that underwent internal fixation for femoral neck fracture using dual sliding and compression screws (DSCS) with 20 mm threads. The existence of incomplete thread engagement and fixation failure (cut out, perforation, pseudoarthrosis, or femoral neck shortening) were evaluated on anteroposterior hip radiography postoperatively. The distances from the thread end to the fracture line, screw head to the femoral head cortex, and femoral head diameter were measured to analyze their relationships with any incomplete thread engagement and fixation failure. Differences in evaluation data were assessed using Fisher's exact test, Student's t -test, and receiver operating characteristic (ROC) analysis. Results Forty-six cases had at least one screw with incomplete thread engagement, and the other 87 hips had a complete engagement. The failure rate in the group of hips with incomplete thread engagement was significantly higher (7/46, 15.2%) than that in the group of hips with complete thread engagement (3/87, 3.4%) (P = 0.032). Incomplete thread engagement was found in 59 out of 266 screws (22.2%), and a femoral head <= 43.9 mm in diameter was associated with an increased risk of incomplete thread engagement. Most incomplete thread engagement screws (81.4%) had < 5 mm thread length within the distal fragment. Conclusion A partially threaded screw is a significant risk of fixation failure after internal fixation for a femoral neck fracture. The smaller femoral head diameter increases the possibility of incomplete thread engagement. Shortening the thread length by 5 mm may help to avoid incomplete thread engagement.