Polysemy does not exist, at least not in the relevant sense

被引:2
|
作者
Brody, Gabor [1 ,2 ]
Feiman, Roman [1 ]
机构
[1] Brown Univ, Dept Cognit Linguist & Psychol Sci, Providence, RI USA
[2] Brown Univ, Dept Cognit Linguist & Psychol Sci, Metcalf Res Labs 240, 190 Thayer St, Providence, RI 02912 USA
关键词
atomism; concepts; copredication; externalism; internalism; polysemy; SEMANTIC AMBIGUITY; REPRESENTATION; LANGUAGE; MEANINGS; WORDS; COPREDICATION; CONSTRAINT; HOMONYMY;
D O I
10.1111/mila.12474
中图分类号
H0 [语言学];
学科分类号
030303 ; 0501 ; 050102 ;
摘要
Based on the existence of polysemy (e.g., lunch can refer to both food and events), it is argued that central tenets of externalist semantics and Fodorian concept atomism, an externalist theory on which words lack semantic structure, are unsound. We evaluate the premise that these arguments rely on-that polysemous words have separate, finer-grained senses. We survey the evidence across psychology and linguistics and argue that it shows that polysemy does not exist, at least not in this "sense". The upshot is that if polysemy does not exist, it cannot pose a problem for atomism or externalism.
引用
收藏
页码:179 / 200
页数:22
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [11] The European public sphere does not exist (At least it's worth wondering...)
    Baisnee, Olivier
    EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF COMMUNICATION, 2007, 22 (04) : 493 - 503
  • [12] Short essay to show that polysemy is not a forbidden sense
    Kleiber, Georges
    1ER CONGRES MONDIAL DE LINGUISTIQUE FRANCAISE: CMLF 2008, PROCEEDINGS, 2008, : 87 - 101
  • [13] Preverbs in Medieval French: polysemy and grammatical sense
    Dufresne, Monique
    Dupuis, Fernande
    Tremblay, Mireille
    1ER CONGRES MONDIAL DE LINGUISTIQUE FRANCAISE: CMLF 2008, PROCEEDINGS, 2008, : 187 - 197
  • [14] THE MARGINAL DOES NOT EXIST BECAUSE THE CENTER DOES NOT EXIST
    Katchadjian, Pablo
    CUADERNOS HISPANOAMERICANOS, 2024, (882) : 20 - 23
  • [15] Synonymy and high-level markers: conceptual sense, associative sense, polysemy
    Le Pesant, Denis
    JOURNAL OF FRENCH LANGUAGE STUDIES, 2020, 30 (01) : 101 - 102
  • [16] Regular polysemy and novel word-sense identification
    Lombard, Alizee
    Huyghe, Richard
    Barque, Lucie
    Gras, Doriane
    MENTAL LEXICON, 2023, 18 (01): : 94 - 119
  • [17] Word Sense Disambiguation of Polysemy Words in Kannada Language
    Shashank, N. S.
    Kallimani, Jagadish S.
    2017 INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE ON ADVANCES IN COMPUTING, COMMUNICATIONS AND INFORMATICS (ICACCI), 2017, : 641 - 644
  • [18] Does polysemy support radical contextualism? On the relation between minimalism, contextualism and polysemy
    Loehr, Guido
    INQUIRY-AN INTERDISCIPLINARY JOURNAL OF PHILOSOPHY, 2024, 67 (01): : 68 - 92
  • [19] "AN ARCHAEOLOGICAL MUSEUM IN THE PROPER SENSE OF THE WORD STILL DOES NOT EXIST". PETROGRAD: PROJECTS AND PLANS OF 1917
    Ananyev, Vitaliy G.
    ROSSIISKAYA ARKHEOLOGIYA, 2017, (02): : 172 - 177
  • [20] Sense Representation in MARVS-A Case Study on the Polysemy of chi
    Wang, Shan
    Huang, Chu-Ren
    11TH CHINESE LEXICAL SEMANTICS WORKSHOP (CKSW2010), 2010, : 22 - 29