Polysemy does not exist, at least not in the relevant sense

被引:2
|
作者
Brody, Gabor [1 ,2 ]
Feiman, Roman [1 ]
机构
[1] Brown Univ, Dept Cognit Linguist & Psychol Sci, Providence, RI USA
[2] Brown Univ, Dept Cognit Linguist & Psychol Sci, Metcalf Res Labs 240, 190 Thayer St, Providence, RI 02912 USA
关键词
atomism; concepts; copredication; externalism; internalism; polysemy; SEMANTIC AMBIGUITY; REPRESENTATION; LANGUAGE; MEANINGS; WORDS; COPREDICATION; CONSTRAINT; HOMONYMY;
D O I
10.1111/mila.12474
中图分类号
H0 [语言学];
学科分类号
030303 ; 0501 ; 050102 ;
摘要
Based on the existence of polysemy (e.g., lunch can refer to both food and events), it is argued that central tenets of externalist semantics and Fodorian concept atomism, an externalist theory on which words lack semantic structure, are unsound. We evaluate the premise that these arguments rely on-that polysemous words have separate, finer-grained senses. We survey the evidence across psychology and linguistics and argue that it shows that polysemy does not exist, at least not in this "sense". The upshot is that if polysemy does not exist, it cannot pose a problem for atomism or externalism.
引用
收藏
页码:179 / 200
页数:22
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [1] Does Consciousness Exist?-In What Sense?
    Allakhverdov, Victor M.
    Gershkovich, Valeria A.
    INTEGRATIVE PSYCHOLOGICAL AND BEHAVIORAL SCIENCE, 2010, 44 (04) : 340 - 347
  • [2] Does Consciousness Exist?—In What Sense?
    Victor M. Allakhverdov
    Valeria A. Gershkovich
    Integrative Psychological and Behavioral Science, 2010, 44 : 340 - 347
  • [3] THEOLOGY OR THERAPY? In What Sense Does Depression Exist?
    Swinton, John
    PHILOSOPHY PSYCHIATRY & PSYCHOLOGY, 2015, 22 (04) : 295 - 298
  • [4] THE SEVERITY OF HEROIN DEPENDENCE: DOES IT EXIST AND IS IT CLINICALLY RELEVANT?
    Shand, Fiona L.
    Slade, Tim
    Degenhardt, Louisa
    Nelson, Elliot C.
    DRUG AND ALCOHOL REVIEW, 2009, 28 : A58 - A58
  • [5] Polysemy: Pragmatics and sense conventions
    Carston, Robyn
    MIND & LANGUAGE, 2021, 36 (01) : 108 - 133
  • [6] Atherosclerosis in contemporary preindustrial populations: does it exist and is it clinically relevant?
    Gurven, Michael D.
    Trumble, Benjamin C.
    Stieglitz, Jonathan
    Beheim, Bret
    Blackwell, Aaron D.
    Michalik, David
    Allam, Adel H.
    Rowan, Christopher
    Frohlich, Bruno
    Sutherland, Linda
    Sutherland, James D.
    Min, James K.
    Finch, Caleb E.
    Wann, Samuel
    Thompson, Randall C.
    Thomas, Gregory S.
    Kaplan, Hillard S.
    AMERICAN JOURNAL OF PHYSICAL ANTHROPOLOGY, 2017, 162 : 205 - 205
  • [7] DOES DEVALUATION MAKE SENSE IN THE LEAST DEVELOPED-COUNTRIES
    GYLFASON, T
    RADETZKI, M
    ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT AND CULTURAL CHANGE, 1991, 40 (01) : 1 - 25
  • [8] Polysemy Detection in Distributed Representation of Word Sense
    Oomoto, Kana
    Oikawa, Haruka
    Yamamoto, Eiko
    Yoshida, Mitsuo
    Okabe, Masayuki
    Umemura, Kyoji
    2017 9TH INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE ON KNOWLEDGE AND SMART TECHNOLOGY (KST), 2017, : 28 - 33
  • [9] Making Sense of Word Senses: The Comprehension of Polysemy Depends on Sense Overlap
    Klepousniotou, Ekaterini
    Titone, Debra
    Romero, Carolina
    JOURNAL OF EXPERIMENTAL PSYCHOLOGY-LEARNING MEMORY AND COGNITION, 2008, 34 (06) : 1534 - 1543
  • [10] Grammatically relevant aspects of meaning and verbal polysemy
    McNally, Louise
    Spalek, Alexandra Anna
    LINGUISTICS, 2022, 60 (06) : 1943 - 1987