Ecological distributions of Chaoborus species in small, shallow lakes from the Canadian Boreal Shield ecozone

Small, shallow lakes and ponds are often the dominant landscape features in many regions, but are comparably less studied than larger lakes. Shallow lakes are more likely to lack fish populations; however, it is often difficult to ascertain whether these sites were naturally fishless or lost their fish populations due to anthropogenic or natural stressors. We examined the distributional abundances of four Chaoborus species by identifying and enumerating their larval mandibles in the surface sediments of 146 randomly selected lakes from northwestern Ontario, Canada, to determine the key environmental gradients influencing chaoborid distributions. Chaoborus mandibles were encountered at 110 lakes and, in 65% of those lakes, total counts were ≥10. Direct gradient analyses were then used to show that lakewater total aluminum concentrations (negatively correlated with pH), lakewater sodium concentrations, lake surface area, and maximum water depth were significant predictors of the distributional abundances of Chaoborus. Generalized linear models indicated that Chaoborus species varied in their responses to significant environmental factors. C. (Sayomyia) was not significantly associated with any environmental variable and the abundances of larger chaoborids may be an important biotic factor affecting this taxon. Chaoborus americanus, an indicator of fishless lakes, was significantly correlated with all five key variables and demonstrated a clear threshold of occurrence in relatively small lakes (i.e., <10 ha in surface area). Furthermore, based on the occurrence and abundance of C. americanus, we estimated that 20% of the lakes we surveyed are currently fishless. These lakes significantly differ in several geomorphic and water-chemistry measures compared to the other study lakes.