In this study, we evaluated salt stress responses of 11 soybean genotypes and explored the protective roles of exogenous glutathione (GSH) against salt toxicity by assessing various biochemical and yield-attributing parameters. Exposure of the soybean genotypes to salt stress at the reproductive (R1) stage significantly decreased their yields by down-regulating the yield-contributing parameters as compared with unstressed controls. The highest decrease was found in number of seeds plant−1, yield plant−1, and number of pods plant−1, whereas the lowest decrease was recorded in number of seeds pod−1. Exogenous GSH was found to be effective in improving salinity tolerance, and the highest positive effects of GSH were recorded in terms of yield plant−1, number of seeds plant−1 and number of pods plant−1, whereas its lowest effect was observed with respect to the 100-seed weight. Cluster analysis of the genotypes based on yield-contributing and yield data revealed different levels of salt tolerance. Notably, BINA-01 and -02, and BINA-04 were recognized as the highest and lowest salt-tolerant genotypes, respectively. Furthermore, exogenous GSH alleviated oxidative stress in the representative contrasting genotypes at the vegetative (V3) stage by decreasing salt-induced accumulation of malondialdehyde and hydrogen peroxide. Taken together, our findings revealed that exogenous GSH application can minimize oxidative stress and contribute to the improvement of yield-contributing parameters, leading to improved yield in soybean genotypes under salt stress. Further investigations on molecular aspects will enable us to gain an in-depth understanding of how exogenous GSH can improve salinity tolerance in soybean, particularly at reproductive stage, to discover relevant pathways for biotechnological manipulation.