Response to commentary by Skinner et al. on Regression to the Mean (RTM) in Burke et al.

被引:0
|
作者
Rachel M Burke
Christi Kay
Julie Gazmararian
机构
[1] Emory University,Department of Epidemiology
[2] HealthMPowers,undefined
关键词
Physical Activity; Academic Achievement; Obese Child; Physical Fitness; Parent Involvement;
D O I
暂无
中图分类号
学科分类号
摘要
This letter is a response to commentary by Skinner et al. on an evaluation by Burke et al. of the HealthMPowers program, an elementary-school-based program developed to improve child health and wellness. In their commentary, Skinner et al. make the criticism that our results for changes in BMI-for-Age Z score were simply reflective of Regression to the Mean (RTM). In this response, we show that while some of our results are consistent with RTM, with adjustment we do still observe some small effects in BMI-for-Age Z score over the course of the school year. We conclude that while our evaluation was not definitive, we still believe that programs of similar design to HealthMPowers merit further rigorous study.
引用
收藏
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [21] Response to Provenzano et al. and De Carlo et al.
    Kalchiem-Dekel, Or
    Bestvina, Christine M.
    Gainor, Justin F.
    Drilon, Alexander
    Lin, Jessica J.
    JOURNAL OF THORACIC ONCOLOGY, 2023, 18 (02) : E13 - E14
  • [22] Response to Comments by Timpson et al. and Yu et al.
    Mekel-Bobrov, Nitzan
    Lahn, Bruce T.
    SCIENCE, 2007, 317 (5841)
  • [23] Commentary: Brief response to Walco et al.
    Varni, JW
    JOURNAL OF PEDIATRIC PSYCHOLOGY, 1999, 24 (02) : 171 - 171
  • [24] Response to commentary from Song et al.
    Lahiri, Satadru K.
    Lehnart, Stephan E.
    Reilly, Svetlana
    T. Wehrens, Xander H.
    JOURNAL OF MOLECULAR AND CELLULAR CARDIOLOGY, 2025, 199 : 78 - 79
  • [25] Authors' Response to: Commentary by Johnson et al.
    Kremen, William S.
    Jak, Amy J.
    Panizzon, Matthew S.
    Spoon, Kelly M.
    Franz, Carol E.
    Thompson, Wesley K.
    Jacobson, Kristen C.
    Vasilopoulos, Terrie
    Vuoksimaa, Eero
    Xian, Hong
    Toomey, Rosemary
    Lyons, Michael J.
    INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF EPIDEMIOLOGY, 2014, 43 (02) : 612 - 613
  • [26] Response to the Commentary from Bevelacqua et al.
    Limoli, Charles L.
    Britten, Richard
    Baulch, Janet
    Borak, Tomas
    ENEURO, 2020, 7 (01)
  • [27] Response to commentary by Andrew Sharp et al.
    Messerli, Franz H.
    Schoenenberger-Berzins, Renate
    Messerli, Adrian W.
    JOURNAL OF HYPERTENSION, 2024, 42 (12) : 2217 - 2218
  • [28] Response to Commentary by Mattos et al. (2024)
    Crotty, Karen
    Gartlehner, Gerald
    Viswanathan, Meera
    JOURNAL OF CONSULTING AND CLINICAL PSYCHOLOGY, 2024, 92 (11) : 782 - 783
  • [29] Commentary on Culligan et al.
    Hohenberger, Werner
    COLORECTAL DISEASE, 2012, 14 (04) : 428 - 430
  • [30] Commentary on Wilson et al.
    King, Nancy M. P.
    CLINICAL TRIALS, 2014, 11 (05) : 530 - 531