Post-privatization corporate governance and firm performance: The role of private ownership concentration, identity and board composition

We examine and analyze the post-privatization corporate governance of a sample of 52 newly privatized Egyptian firms over a period of 10 years, from 1995 to 2005. We look at the ownership structure that results from privatization and its evolution; the determinants of private ownership concentration; and the impact of private ownership concentration, identity and board composition on firm performance. We find that the state gives up control over time to the private sector, but still controls, on average. more than 35% of these firms. We also document a trend in private ownership concentration over time, mostly to the benefit of foreign investors. Firm size, sales growth, industry affiliation, and timing and method of privatization seem to play a key role in determining private ownership concentration. Ownership concentration and ownership identity, in particular foreign investors, prove to have a positive impact on firm performance, while employee ownership concentration has a negative one. The higher proportion of outside directors and the change in the board composition following privatization have a positive effect on firm performance. These results could have some important policy implications where private ownership by foreign investors seems to add more value to firms, while selling state-owned enterprises (SOEs) to employees is not recommended. Also, the state is highly advised to relinquish control and allow for changes in the board of directors following privatization as changing ownership, per se, might not have a positive impact on firm performance unless it is coupled with a new management style. Journal of Comparative Economics 37 (4) (2009) 658-673. Arab Academy for Science and Technology, College of Management and Technology, Alexandria, P.O. Box 1029, Egypt; The Egyptian Exchange, 4 (A) El Sherifein St., Down Town, Postal Code 11513, P.O. Box 358, Mohammed Farid, Cairo, Egypt. (C) 2009 Association for Comparative Economic Studies. Published by Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.