Evidence based policy making during times of uncertainty through the lens of future policy makers: four recommendations to harmonise and guide health policy making in the future COMMENT

被引:4
|
作者
Francoise, Margaux [1 ]
Frambourt, Clea [1 ]
Goodwin, Paige [1 ]
Haggerty, Fabian [1 ]
Jacques, Marjolaine [1 ]
Lama, Maya-Lhanze [1 ]
Leroy, Clara [1 ]
Martin, Augustin [1 ]
Calderon, Raquel Melgar [1 ]
Robert, Jean [1 ]
Schulz-Ruthenberg, Elena [1 ]
Tafur, Lina [1 ]
Nasser, Mona [2 ]
Stuwe, Louisa [1 ]
机构
[1] Sci Po, Paris, France
[2] Univ Plymouth, Peninsula Dent Sch, Fac Hlth, Plymouth, Devon, England
关键词
Health policy; Ethics; Evidence based policy making; Policy recommendations;
D O I
10.1186/s13690-022-00898-z
中图分类号
R1 [预防医学、卫生学];
学科分类号
1004 ; 120402 ;
摘要
The Covid-19 pandemic has not only outlined the importance of using evidence in the healthcare policy making process but also the complexity that exists between policymakers and the scientific community. As a matter of fact, scientific data is just one of many other concurrent factors, including economic, social and cultural, that may provide the rationale for policy making. The pandemic has also raised citizens' awareness and represented an unprecedented moment of willingness to access and understand the evidence underpinning health policies. This commentary provides policy recommendations to improve evidence-based policy making in health, through the lens of a young generation of public policy students and future policymakers, enrolled in a 24-hour course at Sciences Po Paris entitled "Evidence-based policy-making in health: theory and practice(s)". Four out of 11 recommendations were prioritised and presented in this commentary which target both policymakers and the scientific community to make better use of evidence-based policy making in health. First, policy makers and scientists should build trusting partnerships with citizens and engage them, especially those facing our target health care issues or systems. Second, while artificial intelligence raises new opportunities in healthcare, its use in contexts of uncertainty should be addressed by policymakers in terms of liability and ethics. Third, conflicts of interest must be disclosed as much as possible and effectively managed to (re) build a trust relationship between policymakers, the scientific community and citizens, implying the need for risk management tools and cross border disclosure mechanisms. Last, well-designed and secure health information systems need to be implemented, following the FAIR (findable, accessible, interoperable and reusable) principles for health data. This will take us a step further from data to 'policy wisdom'. Overall, these recommendations identified and formulated by students highlight some key issues that need to be rethought in the health policy cycle through elements like institutional incentives, cultural changes and dialogue between policy makers and the scientific community. This input from a younger generation of students highlights the importance of making the conversation on evidence-based policy making in health accessible to all generations and backgrounds.
引用
收藏
页数:5
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [41] Evidence-based Health Policy Decision Making - the Example of occupational Skin Cancer
    Schmitt, J.
    Bauer, A.
    Seidler, A.
    Diepgen, T.
    JOURNAL DER DEUTSCHEN DERMATOLOGISCHEN GESELLSCHAFT, 2013, 11 : 25 - 25
  • [42] Unravelling the effects of straw return on rice production in central China: Evidence for future policy-making
    Shen, Xue
    Jin, Shan
    Liang, Zhihui
    Ao, Rongjun
    SOIL USE AND MANAGEMENT, 2024, 40 (04)
  • [43] Future public policy and its knowledge base: shaping worldviews through counterfactual world-making
    Hillgren, Per-Anders
    Light, Ann
    Strange, Michael
    POLICY DESIGN AND PRACTICE, 2020, 3 (02) : 109 - 122
  • [44] Proper Sleep During Pregnancy for Mental Health of Newborn: An Evidence Based Appeal to Policy Makers
    Kamalesh K. Gulia
    Velayudhan Mohan Kumar
    Sleep and Vigilance, 2018, 2 (1) : 97 - 98
  • [45] Regional Disparities in the Distribution of Health Care Facilities: Building Evidence for Evidence-Based Policy Making
    Anjomshoa, Mina
    Mousavi, Seyyed Meysam
    IRANIAN JOURNAL OF PUBLIC HEALTH, 2014, 43 (07) : 1020 - 1021
  • [46] Entitled To Be Heard: Improving Evidence-Based Policy Making Through Audience and Public Reason
    Rhee, Will
    INDIANA LAW JOURNAL, 2010, 85 (04) : 1315 - 1332
  • [47] Health and healthcare in transitional Europe - Evidence based policy making and greater public participation are needed
    Fister, K
    McKee, M
    BRITISH MEDICAL JOURNAL, 2005, 331 (7510): : 169 - +
  • [48] Advocacy for Evidence-Based Policy-Making in Public Health: Experiences and the Way Forward
    Gupta, Deepak
    Narain, Jai Prakash
    Yadav, S. J.
    JOURNAL OF HEALTH MANAGEMENT, 2021, 23 (01) : 85 - 94
  • [49] The role of an exergy-based building stock model for exploration of future decarbonisation scenarios and policy making
    Garcia Kerdan, Ivan
    Raslan, Rokia
    Ruyssevelt, Paul
    Morillon Galvez, David
    ENERGY POLICY, 2017, 105 : 467 - 483
  • [50] A qualitative exploration of evidence-based decision making in public health practice and policy: the perceived usefulness of a diabetes economic model for decision makers
    Grove, Amy
    Sanders, Tom
    Salway, Sarah
    Goyder, Elizabeth
    Hampshaw, Susan
    EVIDENCE & POLICY, 2019, 15 (04): : 461 - 487