Accuracy of thoracic vertebral body screw placement using standard fluoroscopy, fluoroscopic image guidance, and computed tomographic image guidance - A cadaver study

Study Design. A surgical simulation study in human cadaver spine specimens was conducted to evaluate the accuracy of thoracic vertebral body screw placement using four different intraoperative imaging techniques. Objective. To compare standard fluoroscopy, fluoroscopy-based image guidance with two different referencing methods, and computed tomography-based image guidance by the measuring the time required for screw placement, the radiation exposure to specimen and surgeon, and the accuracy of screw position in the thoracic spine. Summary of Background Data. Image guidance provides additional anatomic information to the surgeon and may improve safety of technically difficult surgical procedures. The placement of screws in the thoracic spine is a technically demanding procedure in which inaccurate screw positioning places the spinal cord, nerve roots, and paraspinal structures such as the aorta and pleural space at risk for injury. Image-guided surgery may improve the accuracy of thoracic screw placement. Methods. Using four different intraoperative imaging methods, two experienced surgeons placed 337 vertebral body screws through the pedicles of thoracic vertebrate in 20 human cadaver thoracic spine specimens. The specimens than were examined with radiographs, computed tomography, and anatomic dissection to determine screw position. Measurements included procedure, setup and screw insertion time, radiation exposure to the specimen, the surgeon's hand, the surgeon's body, frequency, directional, and magnitude of screw perforation through the cortical margins of thoracic vertebrate. Results. As compared with surgery using standard fluoroscopy, fluoroscopy-based image guidance that uses multiple reference marks and computed tomography-based image guidance improves the accuracy of thoracic vertebral body screws placement and the specimen radiation exposure. Exposure to radiation is minimal at the surgeon's hand level and dependent on surgical technique at the surgeon's hand level. Screw perforation occurs most frequently in the lateral direction. Conclusions. Fluoroscopy-based image guidance that uses only a single reference marker for the entire thoracic spine is highly inaccurate and unsafe. Systems with registration based on the instrumented vertebrate provide more accurate placement of thoracic vertebral body screws than standard fluoroscopy, but expose the patient to more radiation and require more time for screw insertion.