Undemocratic Climate Protests

被引:3
|
作者
Garcia-Gibson, Francisco [1 ]
机构
[1] INEO CIF CONICET, Minones 2073, RA-1428 Buenos Aires, DF, Argentina
关键词
OUTCOMES;
D O I
10.1111/japp.12548
中图分类号
B82 [伦理学(道德学)];
学科分类号
摘要
Climate change activists sometimes engage in protests that exert coercion on governments, businesses, and citizens, instead of protests that just attempt to persuade them. I argue that these coercive protests are sometimes undemocratic, despite recent attempts in the literature to describe them as democratic. Coercive climate protests do not always improve deliberative decision-making, and they are a means of exerting control over official decisions that is not available to all affected. I then claim that the fact that some of these protests are undemocratic is not a decisive objection against them. Climate change poses such an extremely serious threat to basic rights worldwide - risking hundreds of millions of lives - that people's right to democracy is outweighed when infringing it is a necessary means for achieving climate change mitigation.
引用
收藏
页码:162 / 179
页数:18
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [21] AN UNDEMOCRATIC MESS
    KILLINGWORTH, M
    NEW STATESMAN & SOCIETY, 1993, 6 (257): : 28 - 28
  • [22] UNDEMOCRATIC MEASURES
    BISCULA, AC
    OYSTER, JL
    AMERICAN BAR ASSOCIATION JOURNAL, 1983, 69 (FEB): : 134 - 134
  • [23] Democracy against Climate Change. John Dewey and the Contemporary Climate Protests
    Kersting, Daniel
    ALLGEMEINE ZEITSCHRIFT FUR PHILOSOPHIE, 2023, 48 (02): : 275 - 298
  • [24] Marching against climate inaction. A quantitative ethnography of climate protests in France
    Gaborit, Maxime
    Le Lann, Yann
    Solnon, Anaelle
    Touzet, Hugo
    POLITIX, 2024, (145) : 135 - 162
  • [25] Caring as an undemocratic virtue
    Vokey, D
    PHILOSOPHY OF EDUCATION 1999, 2000, : 352 - 355
  • [26] MAASTRICHT TREATY UNDEMOCRATIC
    FORDHAM, EJ
    NATURE, 1993, 364 (6440) : 752 - 752
  • [27] Are term limits undemocratic?
    Elhauge, E
    UNIVERSITY OF CHICAGO LAW REVIEW, 1997, 64 (01): : 83 - 201
  • [28] Why secession is undemocratic
    Arteta, Mikel
    REVISTA DE FILOSOFIA-MADRID, 2015, 40 (01): : 157 - 180
  • [29] Climate summits and protests have a strong impact on climate change media coverage in Germany
    Lochner, Jakob H.
    Stechemesser, Annika
    Wenz, Leonie
    COMMUNICATIONS EARTH & ENVIRONMENT, 2024, 5 (01):
  • [30] Our Undemocratic Schools?
    Bartky, John A.
    SCHOOL AND SOCIETY, 1954, 79 (2036): : 196 - 198