Abstract Argumentation Frameworks with Fallible Evidence

被引:1
|
作者
Skiba, Kenneth [1 ]
Thimm, Matthias [1 ]
Cohen, Andrea [2 ]
Gottifredi, Sebastian [2 ]
Garcia, Alejandro J. [2 ]
机构
[1] Univ Koblenz Landau, Mainz, Germany
[2] Univ Nacl Sur, CONICET, Bahia Blanca, Buenos Aires, Argentina
来源
COMPUTATIONAL MODELS OF ARGUMENT (COMMA 2020) | 2020年 / 326卷
关键词
abstract argumentation; computational complexity; evidence retrieval cost; ACCEPTABILITY; SUPPORT;
D O I
10.3233/FAIA200518
中图分类号
TP18 [人工智能理论];
学科分类号
081104 ; 0812 ; 0835 ; 1405 ;
摘要
We consider a generalisation of abstract argumentation frameworks where arguments need to be backed by pieces of evidence in order to be actually present in the argumentation framework. These pieces of evidence come with an associated cost for retrieval and may not be available at any given time. We model an information-seeking agent in this scenario that aims at deciding whether a certain argument is acceptable while minimising the total evidence retrieval cost. We investigate the computational complexity of decision variants of this optimisation problem and find that, depending on the underlying classical argumentation semantics, complexity rises one level in the polynomial hierarchy compared to the classical case.
引用
收藏
页码:347 / 354
页数:8
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [41] On Acceptability in Abstract Argumentation Frameworks with an Extended Defeat Relation
    Martinez, Diego C.
    Garcia, Alejandro J.
    Simari, Guillermo R.
    COMPUTATIONAL MODELS OF ARGUMENT, 2006, 144 : 273 - 278
  • [42] Removed Set-Based Revision of Abstract Argumentation Frameworks
    Nouioua, Farid
    Wuerbel, Eric
    2014 IEEE 26TH INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE ON TOOLS WITH ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE (ICTAI), 2014, : 784 - 791
  • [43] Computation with varied-strength attacks in abstract argumentation frameworks
    Dunne, Paul E.
    Martinez, Diego C.
    Garcia, Alejandro J.
    Simari, Guillermo R.
    COMPUTATIONAL MODELS OF ARGUMENT: PROCEEDINGS OF COMMA 2010, 2010, 216 : 207 - 218
  • [44] The Computational Complexity of Ideal Semantics I: Abstract Argumentation Frameworks
    Dunne, Paul E.
    COMPUTATIONAL MODELS OF ARGUMENT, PROCEEDINGS OF COMMA 2008, 2008, 172 : 147 - 158
  • [45] Revisiting the Notion of Extension over Incomplete Abstract Argumentation Frameworks
    Fazzinga, Bettina
    Flesca, Sergio
    Furfaro, Filippo
    PROCEEDINGS OF THE TWENTY-NINTH INTERNATIONAL JOINT CONFERENCE ON ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE, 2020, : 1712 - 1718
  • [46] Dynamics in Abstract Argumentation Frameworks with Recursive Attack and Support Relations
    Alfano, Gianvincenzo
    Cohen, Andrea
    Gottifredi, Sebastian
    Greco, Sergio
    Parisi, Francesco
    Ricardo, Guillermo
    ECAI 2020: 24TH EUROPEAN CONFERENCE ON ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE, 2020, 325 : 577 - 584
  • [47] THE STATUS OF ARGUMENTS IN ABSTRACT ARGUMENTATION FRAMEWORKS. A TABLEAUX METHOD
    Bodanza, Gustavo A.
    Hernandez-Manfredini, Enrique
    MANUSCRITO, 2023, 46 (02) : 66 - 108
  • [48] Abstract and Concrete Decision Graphs for Choosing Extensions of Argumentation Frameworks
    Dauphin, Jeremie
    Cramer, Marcos
    van der Torre, Leendert
    COMPUTATIONAL MODELS OF ARGUMENT (COMMA 2018), 2018, 305 : 437 - 444
  • [49] On the Computation of Top-k Extensions in Abstract Argumentation Frameworks
    Jabbour, Said
    Raddaoui, Badran
    Sais, Lakhdar
    Salhi, Yakoub
    ECAI 2016: 22ND EUROPEAN CONFERENCE ON ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE, 2016, 285 : 913 - 920
  • [50] AGM Meets Abstract Argumentation: Expansion and Revision for Dung Frameworks
    Baumann, Ringo
    Brewka, Gerhard
    PROCEEDINGS OF THE TWENTY-FOURTH INTERNATIONAL JOINT CONFERENCE ON ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE (IJCAI), 2015, : 2734 - 2740