Early Gedanken experiments of quantum mechanics revisited

被引:0
|
作者
Shi, Y [1 ]
机构
[1] Univ Cambridge, Cavendish Lab, Cambridge CB3 0HE, England
关键词
entanglement; uncertainty relation; Einstein-Bohr debate; Copenhagen interpretation;
D O I
10.1002/1521-3889(200009)9:8<637::AID-ANDP637>3.0.CO;2-N
中图分类号
O4 [物理学];
学科分类号
0702 ;
摘要
The famous gedanken experiments of quantum mechanics have played crucial roles in developing the Copenhagen interpretation. They are studied here from the perspective of standard quantum mechanics, with no ontological interpretation involved. Bohr's investigation of these gedanken experiments, based on the uncertainty relation with his interpretation, was the origin of the Copenhagen interpretation and is still widely adopted, but is shown to be not consistent with the quantum mechanical view. We point out that in most of these gedanken experiments, entanglement plays a crucial role, while its buildup does not change the uncertainty of the concerned quantity in the way thought by Bohr. Especially, in the gamma ray microscope and recoiling double-slit gedanken experiments. we expose the entanglement based on momentum exchange. It is shown that even in such cases, the loss of interference is only due to the entanglement with other degrees of freedom, while the uncertainty relation argument, which has not been questioned up to now, is not right.
引用
收藏
页码:637 / 648
页数:12
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [41] COMPUTER-SUPPORTED GEDANKEN-EXPERIMENTS
    VAZSONYI, A
    INTERFACES, 1982, 12 (04) : 34 - 41
  • [42] Gedanken experiments with Casimir forces and vacuum energy
    Maclay, G. Jordan
    PHYSICAL REVIEW A, 2010, 82 (03):
  • [43] A Special Issue on Theory and Experiments on Foundations of Quantum Mechanics
    Genovese, Marco
    Kulik, Sergei
    Paris, Matteo G. A.
    ADVANCED SCIENCE LETTERS, 2009, 2 (04) : 405 - 406
  • [44] Student interpretations of uncertainty in classical and quantum mechanics experiments
    Stein, Martin M.
    White, Courtney
    Passante, Gina
    Holmes, N. G.
    2019 PHYSICS EDUCATION RESEARCH CONFERENCE, 2019, : 573 - 578
  • [45] Translations in quantum mechanics revisited. The point spectrum case
    Martinez-Perez, Armando
    Torres-Vega, Gabino
    CANADIAN JOURNAL OF PHYSICS, 2016, 94 (12) : 1365 - 1368
  • [46] Some Experiments That Question the Completeness of Orthodox Quantum Mechanics
    Araujo, J.
    Cordovil, J.
    Croca, J. R.
    Moreira, R. N.
    da Silva, A. Rica
    ADVANCED SCIENCE LETTERS, 2009, 2 (04) : 481 - 487
  • [47] Qubit quantum mechanics with correlated-photon experiments
    Galvez, Enrique J.
    AMERICAN JOURNAL OF PHYSICS, 2010, 78 (05) : 510 - 519
  • [48] Simple Gedanken Experiments in Leveraging Applications of Formal Methods
    Boute, Raymond
    LEVERAGING APPLICATIONS OF FORMAL METHODS, VERIFICATION AND VALIDATION, PROCEEDINGS, 2008, 17 : 847 - 861
  • [49] The puzzle of canonical transformations in early quantum mechanics
    Lacki, Jan
    STUDIES IN HISTORY AND PHILOSOPHY OF MODERN PHYSICS, 2004, 35B (03): : 317 - 344
  • [50] Stories from the early days of quantum mechanics
    Rabi, Isidor Isaac
    PHYSICS TODAY, 2025, 78 (01) : 11 - 17