Social class bias in welfare sanctioning judgements: Experimental evidence from a nationally representative sample

被引:2
|
作者
de Vries, Robert [1 ]
Reeves, Aaron [2 ]
Geiger, Ben [1 ]
机构
[1] Univ Kent, Sch Social Policy Sociol & Social Res, Canterbury, Kent, England
[2] Univ Oxford, Dept Social Policy & Intervent, Oxford, England
关键词
benefits; bias; deservingness; discrimination; sanctions; social class; underclass; welfare; DESERVINGNESS; POLITICS; WORKFARE; VIGNETTE; RACE;
D O I
10.1111/spol.12812
中图分类号
F0 [经济学]; F1 [世界各国经济概况、经济史、经济地理]; C [社会科学总论];
学科分类号
0201 ; 020105 ; 03 ; 0303 ;
摘要
In this study, we examine whether welfare deservingness judgements in the United Kingdom are affected by a bias against claimants from stigmatised social class backgrounds. In the United Kingdom, as in other countries, stereotypes of a perceived social 'underclass' are widespread. Political and media discourse frequently portrays members of this 'underclass' as lazy, feckless and not genuinely in need of support. Yet despite strong academic interest in perceived welfare deservingness, existing research has largely neglected the role of social class bias in deservingness judgements. To address this gap, we use a novel vignette experiment administered to a representative sample of British respondents to provide the first direct evidence of discrimination against welfare claimants with 'underclass' signifiers. We find that the British public are more likely to endorse a sanction against a claimant from an 'underclass' background than against an otherwise identical claimant from a less stigmatised class background. We also asked respondents to justify their decisions and, applying computational methods to analyse these free-text responses, we find that 'underclass' claimants are more likely to be blamed for violating the conditions of their benefit, while claimants from other class backgrounds are more often given the 'benefit of the doubt.' Our findings have important implications for our understanding of the relationship between social class background and public deservingness perceptions, and potentially for the differential treatment of claimants by the benefits system.
引用
收藏
页码:843 / 858
页数:16
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [31] DOES SPOUSAL CAREGIVING INCREASE RISK OF INCIDENT HYPERTENSION?: EVIDENCE FROM A NATIONALLY REPRESENTATIVE SAMPLE
    Capistrant, B. D.
    Glymour, M.
    GERONTOLOGIST, 2011, 51 : 5 - 5
  • [32] A latent class analysis of trauma based on a nationally representative sample of US adolescents
    McChesney, Gillian C.
    Adamson, Gary
    Shevlin, Mark
    SOCIAL PSYCHIATRY AND PSYCHIATRIC EPIDEMIOLOGY, 2015, 50 (08) : 1207 - 1217
  • [33] Empirical subtyping of alcohol dependence in a nationally representative sample: A latent class analysis
    Moss, H. B.
    Chen, C. M.
    Yi, H.
    ALCOHOLISM-CLINICAL AND EXPERIMENTAL RESEARCH, 2006, 30 (06) : 166A - 166A
  • [34] The influence of social health on cognition: results from a nationally representative sample of older adults.
    Kotwal, A. A.
    Waite, L.
    Schumm, P.
    Shega, J.
    McClintock, M.
    Dale, W.
    JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN GERIATRICS SOCIETY, 2013, 61 : S12 - S12
  • [35] Correlates of treatment seeking in individuals with social anxiety disorder: Findings from a nationally representative sample
    Patel, Tapan A.
    Schubert, Frederick T.
    Hom, Melanie A.
    Cougle, Jesse R.
    JOURNAL OF ANXIETY DISORDERS, 2022, 91
  • [36] Posttraumatic Stress Disorder in Diverse Populations: Testing for Assessment Bias in a Nationally Representative Sample
    Gutierrez, Carolina I.
    Arteaga, Katherina
    Schepis, Ty S.
    De Nadai, Alessandro S.
    PSYCHOLOGICAL TRAUMA-THEORY RESEARCH PRACTICE AND POLICY, 2024, 16 (08) : 1252 - 1259
  • [37] Cannabis use and social anxiety disorder in emerging adulthood: Results from a nationally representative sample
    Single, Alanna
    Alcolado, Gillian
    Keough, Matthew T.
    Mota, Natalie
    JOURNAL OF ANXIETY DISORDERS, 2024, 101
  • [38] Regrets of the Typical American: Findings From a Nationally Representative Sample
    Morrison, Mike
    Roese, Neal J.
    SOCIAL PSYCHOLOGICAL AND PERSONALITY SCIENCE, 2011, 2 (06) : 576 - 583
  • [39] Creating a Nationally Representative Sample of Patients From Trauma Centers
    Goble, Sandra
    Neal, Melanie
    Clark, David E.
    Nathens, Avery B.
    Annest, J. Lee
    Faul, Mark
    Sattin, Richard W.
    Li, Lei
    Levy, Paul S.
    Mann, N. Clay
    Guice, Karen
    Cassidy, Laura D.
    Fildes, John J.
    JOURNAL OF TRAUMA-INJURY INFECTION AND CRITICAL CARE, 2009, 67 (03): : 637 - 644
  • [40] Emotion dysregulation in misophonia: Findings from a nationally representative sample
    Dixon, Laura J.
    Sevier, Carey J.
    Freshley, Alexandra M.
    JOURNAL OF PSYCHIATRIC RESEARCH, 2024, 180 : 266 - 272