Are Good Code Reviewers Also Good at Design Review?

被引：0

作者：

Uwano, Hidetake ^{[1
]}

Monden, Akito ^{[1
]}

Matsumoto, Ken-ichi ^{[1
]}

机构：

[1] Nara Inst Sci & Technol, Grad Sch Informat Sci, Takayama, Ikoma 89165, Japan

来源：

ESEM'08: PROCEEDINGS OF THE 2008 ACM-IEEE INTERNATIONAL SYMPOSIUM ON EMPIRICAL SOFTWARE ENGINEERING AND MEASUREMENT | 2008年

关键词：

Code review; design review; experimental evaluation;

D O I：

暂无

中图分类号：

TP31 [计算机软件];

学科分类号：

081202 ; 0835 ;

摘要：

Software review is a necessity activity to build high reliability software in software development. In this paper, we experimentally analyze the difference in performance between two types of (checklist based) software reviews: design review and code review. If good code reviewers were also good at design review, then we should assign good code reviewers to the design review too. If not, that means these two reviews require different types of expertise. In our experiment, with ten review participants, we examined two hypotheses each related to the defect detection ratio and the required time to find a defect. As a result, we found that there was no correlation between two reviews, i.e. good code reviewers were not necessarily the good design reviewers. This suggests the need of a completely different training program for each review.

引用

页码：351 / 353

页数：3

共 50 条

[21] Whatever was good for business was also good for society -: How are things today?
Grönroos, C
EKONOMISKA SAMFUNDETS TIDSKRIFT, 2000, 53 (01): : 89 - 90
[22] The Good Reader of Digital World, Digital Natives: Are They Good Writer Also?
Gulsecen, Sevinc
Ozdemir, Sebnem
Gezer, Murat
Akadal, Emre
Proceedings of 6th World Conference on Educational Sciences, 2015, 191 : 2396 - 2401
[23] IS YOUR GOOD COUNSEL ALSO WISE
ALDISERT, RJ
UNIVERSITY OF PITTSBURGH LAW REVIEW, 1968, 29 (03) : 414 - 433
[24] Exercise is good also for a healthy hippocampus
Canbolat, M.
Kafkas, A. S.
Erbay, M. F.
Senol, D.
Cevirgen, F.
Senol, P.
Ozbag, D.
BRATISLAVA MEDICAL JOURNAL-BRATISLAVSKE LEKARSKE LISTY, 2019, 120 (10): : 739 - 743
[25] TECHNICAL CERAMICS ALSO IN GOOD DEMAND
不详
CFI-CERAMIC FORUM INTERNATIONAL, 1995, 72 (07): : 382 - 383
[26] Swift publication would reward good reviewers
Eugene V. Koonin
Nature, 2003, 422 : 374 - 374
[27] Swift publication would reward good reviewers
Koonin, EV
NATURE, 2003, 422 (6930) : 374 - 374
[28] Good Mobile Design Is Good Business
Salz, Peggy Anne
ECONTENT, 2014, 37 (10) : 8 - 8
[29] GOOD DESIGN IS GOOD BUSINESS INTRODUCTION
不详
ARCHITECTURAL RECORD, 2015, 203 (05) : 103 - 103
[30] COMMENTARY + GOOD DESIGN IS GOOD BUSINESS
BASS, S
GRAPHIS, 1989, 45 (261): : 15 - 15

← 1 2 3 4 5 →