"Meno": Virtue as φρονησισ

被引:0
|
作者
Jankauskas, Skirmantas
机构
来源
LOGOS-VILNIUS | 2022年 / 113期
关键词
virtue; (true) knowledge; prudence; anamnesis; learning;
D O I
10.24101/logos.2022.68
中图分类号
C [社会科学总论];
学科分类号
03 ; 0303 ;
摘要
The article interprets the third part of Meno (86c-96c), which explores whether virtue is learnt. The pursuit of knowledge of virtue arises from the desire to gain it by knowing it. Predicting a hypothetical virtue in general from the perspective of Parmenidean being, it is also assumed that such an entity should belong to the domain of (true) knowledge (epsilon pi iota omicron tau eta mu eta). Presuming that virtue in general belongs to the being it follows that it should also be an entity of the highest ontological order, and that knowing it would therefore simultaneously imply its practical acquisition. The problem of the cognitive status of virtue is solved by a form of hypothetical reasoning borrowed from geometry. Since one can only learn the things of knowledge, virtue could also be learnt if it belonged to the realm of (true) knowledge. Hence, if it turns out that it cannot be learnt, the assumption that virtue is a matter of (true) knowledge would have to be abandoned. To investigate the possibility of learning virtue in life itself, virtue is linked to the understanding (phi rho omicron nu eta sigma iota sigma.) gained from private experience. The examples of eminent historical figures who supposedly possessed understanding show that they failed to pass on the virtues of goodness and wisdom to their descendants. Menon's presentation of Gorgias' view that the Greek sophists taught only eloquence and not virtue leads to the conclusion that virtue is not teachable. This compromises the original premise of the study, that virtue is a matter of (true) knowledge and raises the question of the relation of virtue and the good to being.
引用
收藏
页码:6 / 17
页数:12
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [41] THE 'MENO' AND THE MYSTERIES OF MATHEMATICS
    LLOYD, GER
    PHRONESIS-A JOURNAL FOR ANCIENT PHILOSOPHY, 1992, 37 (02): : 166 - 183
  • [42] THE (MENO)PAUSE THAT REFRESHES
    KING, P
    PSYCHOLOGY TODAY, 1988, 22 (12) : 11 - 11
  • [43] Plato's Meno
    Devereux, Daniel
    PHILOSOPHICAL QUARTERLY, 2008, 58 (233): : 702 - 710
  • [44] Plato, Meno and Phaedo
    Dufour, Richard
    LAVAL THEOLOGIQUE ET PHILOSOPHIQUE, 2011, 67 (03): : 620 - 620
  • [45] Plato: "Protagoras" and "Meno"
    Kowalchuk, Andrea L.
    INTERPRETATION-A JOURNAL OF POLITICAL PHILOSOPHY, 2008, 35 (03): : 291 - 297
  • [46] PROTAGORAS AND MENO - PLATO
    LACEY, AR
    PHILOSOPHY, 1960, 35 (135) : 371 - 372
  • [47] POLANYI ON MENO PARADOX
    BRADIE, M
    PHILOSOPHY OF SCIENCE, 1974, 41 (02) : 203 - 203
  • [48] More on anamnesis in the 'Meno' (Plato)
    Sharples, B
    PHRONESIS-A JOURNAL FOR ANCIENT PHILOSOPHY, 1999, 44 (04): : 353 - 357
  • [49] Optical properties of the MeNO2 ferroelectrics and MeNO3-NO-2 compounds
    Resnick, L.
    FERROELECTRICS, 2006, 339 : 1841 - 1850
  • [50] Ital. meno male
    Serianni, Luca
    ZEITSCHRIFT FUR ROMANISCHE PHILOLOGIE, 2018, 134 (04): : 1197 - 1205