Monocular alignment in different depth planes

We examined (a) whether vertical lilies at different physical horizontal positions in the same eye can appear to be aligned, and (b), if so, whether the difference between the horizontal positions of the aligned vertical lines can vary with the perceived depth between them. In two experiments, each of two vertical monocular lines was presented (in its respective rectangular area) in one field of a random-dot stereopair with binocular disparity. In Experiment 1, 15 observers were asked to align a line in all upper area with a line in a lower area. The results indicated that when the lilies appeared aligned, their horizontal physical positions could differ and the direction of the difference coincided with the type of disparity of the rectangular areas; this is not consistent with the law of the Visual direction of monocular stimuli. In Experiment 2, 11 observers were asked to report relative depth between the two lilies and to align them. The results indicated that the difference of the horizontal position did not covary with their perceived relative depth, suggesting that the visual direction and perceived depth of the Monocular line are mediated via different mechanisms. (C) 2002 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.