Bayesian estimation and model choice in item response models

Item response models are essential tools for analyzing results from many educational and psychological tests. Such models are used to quantify the probability of correct response as a function of unobserved examinee ability and other parameters explaining the difficulty and the discriminatory power of the questions in the test. Sonic of these models also incorporate a threshold parameter for the probability of the correct response to account for the effect of guessing the correct answer in multiple choice type tests. In this article we consider fitting of such models using the Gibbs sampler. A data augmentation method to analyze a normal-ogive model incorporating a threshold guessing parameter is introduced and compared with a Metropolis-Hastings sampling method, The proposed method is an order of magnitude more efficient than the existing method, Another objective of this paper is to develop Bayesian model choice techniques for model discrimination. A predictive approach based oil a variant of the Bayes factor is used and compared with another decision theoretic method which minimizes in expected loss function oil the predictive space. A classical model choice technique based on a modified likelihood ratio test statistic is shown as one component of the second criterion. As a consequence the Bayesian methods proposed in this paper are contrasted with the classical approach based on the likelihood ratio test, Several examples are given to illustrate the methods.