Functional Outcomes of Nonunion Scaphoid Fracture Treated by Pronator Quadratus Pedicled Bone Graft

Between 1998 and 2007, a pronator quadratus pedicled bone graft was performed for 45 patients of ununited scaphoid fracture. One of them had bilateral ununited scaphoid fracture. There were 29 men and 16 women with a median age at operation of 24 (16-32) years. The affected side was the right side (dominant hand) in 32 patients whereas 13 patients had fracture of the nondominant left side. There had been 32 proximal pseudoarthrosis (through or proximal to the junction of the proximal and middle thirds of the bone) and 14 of the middle third of the scaphoid. The original fractures were caused by motor cycle accidents in 23 patients, falling on outstretched hand in 15 patients, and sport injuries in the remaining 7 patients. Surgery was indicated from 5 months to 6 years after injury (average 43 months) because of complaints of pain on heavy work. The fracture has been missed at the initial examination in 23 patients whereas cast immobilization was done for 6 weeks and 3 months in 15 and 7 cases, respectively, that had failed to result in union. There were no preoperative osteoarthritic changes, but in 25 cases, there were avascular necrosis of the proximal fragment of the scaphoid. Forty-three patients showed radiographic union after an average of 14 weeks (12-16 weeks). One patient had dislodgement of the graft and refused to do it again. The average range of movement of wrist improved after operation. Taken as a percentage of the normal range, dorsiflexion increased from 69% to 80%, palmar flexion from 66% to 76%, radial deviation from 45% to 70%, and ulnar deviation from 67% to 84%. Grip strength improved from 82% to 92% of normal. All the patients have been able to return to their former activities with no pain.