A grounding solution to the grounding problem

被引:16
|
作者
Saenz, Noel B. [1 ]
机构
[1] Univ Illinois, Dept Philosophy, Urbana, IL 61801 USA
关键词
Coincidence; Facts; Grounding; Modal; Kind; Parts; CONSTITUTION; COINCIDENCE; SUPERVENIENCE; OBJECTS;
D O I
10.1007/s11098-014-0405-x
中图分类号
B [哲学、宗教];
学科分类号
01 ; 0101 ;
摘要
The statue and the lump of clay that constitutes it fail to share all of their kind and modal properties. Therefore, by Leibniz's Law, the statue is not the lump. Question: What grounds the kind and modal differences between the statue and the lump? In virtue of what is it that the lump of clay, but not the statue, can survive being smashed? This is the grounding problem. Now a number of solutions to the grounding problem require that we substantially revise our view of reality. In this paper, I provide a solution to this problem that does not require such a revision. I then show how my solution to the grounding problem can solve a related problem and answer a related question. The upshot is that the solution I offer is not only non-revisionary, but also fruitful.
引用
收藏
页码:2193 / 2214
页数:22
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [21] Grounding Concepts: The Problem of Composition
    Gabor Forrai
    PHILOSOPHIA, 2011, 39 (04) : 721 - 731
  • [22] The grounding problem and presentist explanations
    Torrengo, Giuliano
    SYNTHESE, 2013, 190 (12) : 2047 - 2063
  • [23] Colocationist Answers to the Grounding Problem
    Campdelacreu, Marta
    THEORIA-A SWEDISH JOURNAL OF PHILOSOPHY, 2021, : 1444 - 1467
  • [24] Grounding and the Epistemic Regress Problem
    Siscoe, Robert Weston
    ERKENNTNIS, 2024, 89 (03) : 875 - 896
  • [25] The grounding problem and presentist explanations
    Giuliano Torrengo
    Synthese, 2013, 190 : 2047 - 2063
  • [26] Grounding and the Epistemic Regress Problem
    Robert Weston Siscoe
    Erkenntnis, 2024, 89 : 875 - 896
  • [27] Exploitation's grounding problem
    Ferguson, Benjamin
    ECONOMICS & PHILOSOPHY, 2024,
  • [28] Grounding 'Grounding' in NLP
    Chandu, Khyathi Raghavi
    Bisk, Yonatan
    Black, Alan W.
    FINDINGS OF THE ASSOCIATION FOR COMPUTATIONAL LINGUISTICS, ACL-IJCNLP 2021, 2021, : 4283 - 4305
  • [29] SUTTON'S SOLUTION TO THE GROUNDING PROBLEM AND INTRINSICALLY COMPOSED COLOCATED OBJECTS
    Campdelacreu, Marta
    CRITICA-REVISTA HISPANOAMERICANA DE FILOSOFIA, 2016, 48 (143): : 77 - 92
  • [30] Well Founding Grounding Grounding
    Rabin, Gabriel Oak
    Rabern, Brian
    JOURNAL OF PHILOSOPHICAL LOGIC, 2016, 45 (04) : 349 - 379