Kinetic isotope effect data for the oxidation of deuterium-substituted methane molecules with methane monooxygenase (MMO) are analyzed in the framework of a multistep nonradical mechanism. New evidence is obtained in favor of the hypothesis of the intermediate formation of a complex containing pentacoordinated carbon. A kinetic scheme whose first step involves two hydrogen molecules of the substrate being oxidized is considered. For coincidence between the calculated and experimental distributions of the oxidation products of partially deuterated methane, the formation of the intermediate complex containing pentacoordinated carbon must be reversible and the rate of the back decomposition of this complex must be substantially higher than the rate of its formation (w(-1) >> w(1)). The experimental distribution of the products of deuterated methane (CH3D, CH2D2, and CHD3) hydroxylation with MMO, which could not earlier be explained within the widely accepted oxygen rebound mechanism, is quantitatively explained for the first time in terms of the dynamics of a nonradical mechanism using parameters having a simple physical meaning and plausible values.