A proclivity for entrepreneurship: A comparison of entrepreneurs, small business owners, and corporate managers

被引:334
|
作者
Stewart, WH
Watson, WE
Carland, JC
Carland, JW
机构
[1] Clemson Univ, Dept Management, Clemson, SC 29634 USA
[2] Univ N Texas, Denton, TX 76203 USA
[3] Western Carolina Univ, Cullowhee, NC 28723 USA
关键词
D O I
10.1016/S0883-9026(97)00070-0
中图分类号
F [经济];
学科分类号
02 ;
摘要
Despite intensive inquiry, relatively little is known about the entrepreneur, the central figure in entrepreneurship. The question of how an individual who operates his or her own business differs from a corporate manager remains unanswered In addressing this question, the primary purpose of this study was to investigate the potential of psychological constructs to predict a proclivity for entrepreneurship. The research model includes three classic themes in the literature: achievement motivation, risk-taking propensity, and preference for innovation. A survey of 767 small business owner-managers and corporate managers was assembled from a 20-state region, primarily the southeastern United States. The participants completed a questionnaire composed of the Achievement Scale of the Personality Research Form, the Risk-Taking and Innovation Scales of the Jackson Personality Inventory and questions pertaining to numerous individual and organizational variables. Respondents were first divided into two groups, managers and small business owner-managers. Subsequently, due to the often cited variations in entrepreneurs, the owner-managers were further categorized as either an entrepreneur or small business owner, using the widely cited Garland et al. (1984) theoretical definitions. Entrepreneurs are defined by their goals of profit and growth for their ventures and by their use of strategic planning. Alternatively small business owners focus on providing family income and view the venture as an extension of their personalities. In this study, both groups of owner-managers were simultaneously compared with managers using hierarchical set multinomial LOGIT regression. The results indicated that the psychological constructs are associated with small business ownership, but With some important caveats. As hypothesized, those labeled entrepreneurs were higher in achievement motivation, risk-taking propensity, and preference for innovation than were both the corporate managers and the small business owners. This profile of the entrepreneur as a driven, creative risk-taker is consistent with much of the classic literature concerning the entrepreneur Nonetheless, not all of the owner-managers fit this profile. When compared with managers, the small business owners demonstrated only a significantly higher risk-taking propensity. In terms of the constructs studied, the small business owners were more comparable to managers than to entrepreneurs. In addition to theoretical and methodological implications, the results presented here have important implications for small business owner-managers of both types. A major issue is the connection between the owner's psychological profile and the characteristics of the venture, including performance. It would appear that psychological antecedents are associated with owner goals for the venture. Some owners will be more growth oriented than will others, and performance should be assessed in light of the owner's aspirations for the venture. Moreover, owners should be aware of their own personality sets, including risk preferences, which may be more or less suited to different venture circumstances, including those with relatively high levels of risk. Planning in small businesses appears to enhance venture performance. Research has demonstrated the connections between psychological factors and planning behaviors in small businesses. Those labeled entrepreneurs in this study have goals of profit and growth, and tend to engage in more planning An awareness of these psychological preferences and concomitant attention to planning behaviors have the potential to improve the performance of the venture, irrespective of owner aspirations. Venture teaming is becoming more popular among entrepreneurs. Balanced venture teams appear to improve the chances of entrepreneurial success (Timmons 1990), but a common source of conflict among venture team members is inconsistent or ambiguous motives for the new venture. Awareness of venture partners' psychological predispositions in areas such as risk-taking could be used to identify and reconcile areas of potential conflict, and enhance the planning process in the small firm. In sum, an individual's awareness of his or her psychological profile provides a number of advantages, not only to existing entrepreneurs, but also to aspiring entrepreneurs who should assess their perceived entrepreneurial opportunities against the backdrop of their psychological proclivity for entrepreneurship. (C) 1998 Elsevier Science Inc.
引用
收藏
页码:189 / 214
页数:26
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [41] Corporate Entrepreneurship and Innovation in Business Practices
    Park, Hong Y.
    2006 KDI-KAEA CONFERENCE ON ENHANCING PRODUCTIVITY AND SUSTAINING GROWTH, 2006, : 135 - 159
  • [42] A study of a university-led entrepreneurship education programme for small business owner/managers
    Gordon, Ian
    Hamilton, Eleanor
    Jack, Sarah
    ENTREPRENEURSHIP AND REGIONAL DEVELOPMENT, 2012, 24 (9-10): : 767 - 805
  • [43] Advice to Entrepreneurs and Small Business
    Mole, Kevin
    FOUNDATIONS AND TRENDS IN ENTREPRENEURSHIP, 2021, 17 (02): : 154 - 231
  • [44] Owners or traders? Conceptualizations of institutional investors and their relationship with corporate managers
    Hendry, John
    Sanderson, Paul
    Barker, Ricbard
    Roberts, Jobn
    HUMAN RELATIONS, 2006, 59 (08) : 1101 - 1132
  • [45] Small business and entrepreneurship in the knowledge economy: A comparison of Australia and Sweden
    Parker, Rachel
    NEW POLITICAL ECONOMY, 2006, 11 (02) : 201 - 226
  • [46] Entrepreneurship and Organised Crime. Entrepreneurs in Illegal Business
    Sauka, Arnis
    INTERNATIONAL SMALL BUSINESS JOURNAL, 2012, 30 (01) : 99 - 101
  • [47] Entrepreneurship and Entrepreneurs in Small Innovative Australian Firms
    Sixsmith, Alan
    Mooney, Grant
    INNOVATION VISION 2020: SUSTAINABLE GROWTH, ENTREPRENEURSHIP, AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT, VOLS 1-4, 2012, : 154 - 163
  • [48] DO SMALL BUSINESS OWNERS CARE? PERCEPTIONS OF SMALL BUSINESSES OWNERS AND THEIR LITERACY
    Isle, Melissa Belle
    Freudenberg, Brett
    Sarker, Tapan
    JOURNAL OF THE AUSTRALASIAN TAX TEACHERS ASSOCIATION, 2023, 18 (01): : 16 - 58
  • [49] Organizational commitment of small business owners
    Chan
    Sow Hup
    SMES CLUSTERS & INNOVATION, 2005, : 53 - 61
  • [50] Business Survival and Success of Young Small Business Owners
    C. Mirjam van Praag
    Small Business Economics, 2003, 21 : 1 - 17