Application of recycled asphalt shingles (RAS) into hot-mix asphalt have been well accepted by many transportation agencies in recent years. However, limited information on virgin-HAS binder blends is available. This study focused on the rheological and chemical characteristics of different blends. Two virgin binders (PG 64-22A and PG 64-22B) and three RAS binders (original RAS binder, extracted HAS binders from tear-off, and manufacture waste asphalt shingles) were used. Different from the well-known linear blending of virgin and reclaimed asphalt pavement binders, the virgin and RAS binder blending followed a nonlinear trend. The nonlinear behavior was found to relate closely to the asphaltene content of the virgin and HAS blends. Furthermore, the identified nonlinear behavior could be described by a simple linear equation because the normalized increase in high-temperature performance grade varied linearly with the increase in the HAS binder content. The Christensen-Anderson (CA) model and the Williams Landel Ferry (WLF) shifting equation successfully described the complex shear modulus behavior of different blends of virgin and HAS binders. The results also showed that adding HAS binders to virgin binders had a similar impact as that of aging on rheological parameters such as the rheological index, crossover frequency, and WLF parameters. The addition of HAS binder reduced the temperature susceptibility of virgin binders. In addition, the study found that the carbonyl area measured with a Fourier transform infrared-attenuated total reflectance spectroscopy was highly related to the CA model and the WLF shifting parameters.