Is cheap talk effective at eliminating hypothetical bias in a provision point mechanism?

被引:106
|
作者
Murphy, JJ
Stevens, TH
Weatherhead, D
机构
[1] Univ Massachusetts, Dept Resource Econ, Amherst, MA 01003 USA
[2] Univ Massachusetts, Ctr Publ Policy & Adm, Amherst, MA 01003 USA
[3] Univ Massachusetts, Dept Resource Econ, Amherst, MA 01002 USA
[4] US EPA, Off Air Qual Planning & Stand, Res Triangle Pk, NC 27711 USA
来源
ENVIRONMENTAL & RESOURCE ECONOMICS | 2005年 / 30卷 / 03期
关键词
contingent valuation; experiments; hypothetical bias; voluntary contributions;
D O I
10.1007/s10640-004-4224-y
中图分类号
F [经济];
学科分类号
02 ;
摘要
Significant difference between response to real and hypothetical valuation questions is often referred to as hypothetical bias. Some economists have had success with using "cheap talk" (which entails reading a script that explicitly highlights the hypothetical bias problem before participants make any decisions) as a means of generating unbiased responses in a referendum format. In this article, we test the robustness of cheap talk using a voluntary contribution mechanism with a provision point over a wide range of possible payment amounts. Our results confirm the existence of hypothetical bias, and suggest that cheap talk may eliminate hypothetical bias, but only for respondents facing higher payments.
引用
收藏
页码:327 / 343
页数:17
相关论文
共 42 条
  • [31] Measuring the Local Costs of Conservation: A Provision Point Mechanism for Eliciting Willingness to Accept Compensation
    Bush, Glenn
    Hanley, Nick
    Moro, Mirko
    Rondeau, Daniel
    LAND ECONOMICS, 2013, 89 (03) : 490 - 513
  • [32] Contributory provision point contracts - A risk-free mechanism for hedging cloud energy costs
    Rogers O.
    Cliff D.
    Journal of Cloud Computing, 2013, 2 (01) : 1 - 18
  • [33] Voluntary funding for generic advertising using a provision point mechanism: An experimental analysis of option assurance
    Messer, Kent D.
    Kaiser, Harry M.
    Poe, Gregory L.
    REVIEW OF AGRICULTURAL ECONOMICS, 2007, 29 (03): : 612 - 631
  • [34] The Utilization of Wireless Handheld Computers with MEDLINE is an Effective Mechanism for Answering Clinical Questions at the Point of Care
    Preddie, Martha Ingrid
    EVIDENCE BASED LIBRARY AND INFORMATION PRACTICE, 2008, 3 (03): : 64 - 67
  • [35] Mechanism of field-induced unwinding of SmC* helix and bias field dependencies of dielectric permittivity and effective polarization
    Song, Jang-Kun
    Manna, U.
    Vij, J. K.
    EPL, 2008, 82 (02)
  • [36] Get The Point of My Utterance! Learning Towards Effective Responses with Multi-Head Attention Mechanism
    Tao, Chongyang
    Gao, Shen
    Shang, Mingyue
    Wu, Wei
    Zhao, Dongyan
    Yan, Rui
    PROCEEDINGS OF THE TWENTY-SEVENTH INTERNATIONAL JOINT CONFERENCE ON ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE, 2018, : 4418 - 4424
  • [37] SUPPRESSION OF IRRADIATION SWELLING THROUGH AN IMPURITY-POINT DEFECT TRAPPING MECHANISM INVOLVING REDUCTION OF THE DISLOCATION BIAS FACTOR
    WEERTMAN, J
    PARKIN, DM
    JOURNAL OF NUCLEAR MATERIALS, 1981, 99 (01) : 66 - 74
  • [38] POSSIBLE MECHANISM OF HIGHLY EFFECTIVE ACCELERATION OF MODIFICATION AND RECOMBINATION OF POINT-DEFECTS IN SEMICONDUCTORS BY IONIZING-RADIATION
    VINETSKII, VL
    KHOLODAR, GA
    SOVIET PHYSICS SEMICONDUCTORS-USSR, 1982, 16 (07): : 848 - 850
  • [39] Reasoning mechanism: An effective data reduction algorithm for on-line point cloud selective sampling of sculptured surfaces
    Li, Yan
    Liu, Haibo
    Tao, Ye
    Liao, Jianxing
    COMPUTER-AIDED DESIGN, 2019, 113 : 48 - 61
  • [40] Mechanism of shale oil as an effective collector for oxidized coal flotation: From bubble-particle attachment and detachment point of view
    Li, Ming
    Xia, Yangchao
    Zhang, Youfei
    Ding, Shihao
    Rong, Guoqiang
    Cao, Yijun
    Xing, Yaowen
    Gui, Xiahui
    FUEL, 2019, 255