Comparative analysis of positioning accuracy of Garmin Forerunner wearable GNSS receivers in dynamic testing

被引:12
|
作者
Szot, Tomasz [1 ]
Specht, Cezary [2 ]
Dabrowski, Pawel S. [2 ]
Specht, Mariusz [3 ]
机构
[1] Gdansk Univ Phys Educ & Sport, Dept Phys Culture, Gdansk, Poland
[2] Gdynia Maritime Univ, Dept Geodesy & Oceanog, Gdynia, Poland
[3] Gdynia Maritime Univ, Dept Transport & Logist, Gdynia, Poland
关键词
GNSS testing; Garmin Forerunner; Validation methodology; Physical activity (PA) trackers; Cross track error (XTE); Wearables' accuracy; PHYSICAL-ACTIVITY; ELITE; GPS; PATTERNS;
D O I
10.1016/j.measurement.2021.109846
中图分类号
T [工业技术];
学科分类号
08 ;
摘要
The article attempts to assess the positioning accuracy of a series of twelve low-cost, code GNSS receivers, manufactured by a single producer (Garmin) in the years 2003-2019, dedicated to runners. The use of such devices in recreation and sports is widespread, but they differ from each other depending on Global Navigation Satellite Systems used and individual characteristics. The surveys were carried out with the use of experimental railway measurement platform, at three speeds (10, 30, 50 km/h). The position accuracy measures commonly used in geodesy and navigation were calculated, as well as Cross Track Error measure for two confidence levels of 68% and 95%. The results demonstrated improvements in accuracy, primarily because of the number of GNSS systems used; e.g. 2011 GPS-only receiver 2DRMS = 10.35 m; 2015 GPS/GLONASS 2DRMS = 8.14 m and 2019 GPS/GLONASS/Galileo 2DRMS = 4.29 m. The test speed did not have a significant effect on the accuracy of the devices.
引用
收藏
页数:11
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [31] Performance analysis of oceanographic research vessel precise point positioning based on BDS/GNSS RTK receivers
    Yan, Xingyuan
    Liu, Chenchen
    Jiang, Mi
    Yang, Meng
    Feng, Wei
    Zhong, Min
    Peng, Lingzhi
    MEASUREMENT, 2023, 211
  • [32] Feasibility Analysis of Low-cost GNSS Receivers for Achieving Required Positioning Performance in CAV Applications
    Cui, Yijian
    Meng, Xiaolin
    Chen, Qusen
    Gao, Yang
    Xu, Chang
    Roberts, Simon
    Wang, Yiting
    2017 FORUM ON COOPERATIVE POSITIONING AND SERVICE (CPGPS), 2017, : 355 - 361
  • [33] Portable device to assess dynamic accuracy of global positioning system (GPS) receivers used in agricultural aircraft
    Thomson, Steven J.
    Huang, Yanbo
    INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF AGRICULTURAL AND BIOLOGICAL ENGINEERING, 2014, 7 (02) : 68 - 74
  • [34] A comparative analysis of the accuracy of positioning techniques in automatic identification system
    Jiang, Yi
    Hu, Qing
    Yang, Dongkai
    ICIC Express Letters, 2015, 9 (01): : 81 - 86
  • [35] Feasibility analysis of the performance of low-cost GNSS receivers in monitoring dynamic motion
    Xue, Chenyu
    Psimoulis, Panos A.
    Meng, Xiaolin
    Measurement: Journal of the International Measurement Confederation, 2022, 202
  • [36] A comparative analysis of the performance of various GNSS positioning concepts dedicated to precision agriculture
    Kowalczyk, Wiktoria Zofia
    Hadas, Tomasz
    REPORTS ON GEODESY AND GEOINFORMATICS, 2024, 117 (01) : 11 - 20
  • [37] Feasibility analysis of the performance of low-cost GNSS receivers in monitoring dynamic motion
    Xue, Chenyu
    Psimoulis, Panos A.
    Meng, Xiaolin
    MEASUREMENT, 2022, 202
  • [38] Performance evaluation of a tracking total station as a position reference for dynamic GNSS accuracy testing
    Sama, Michael P., 1600, American Society of Agricultural and Biological Engineers (30):
  • [39] PERFORMANCE EVALUATION OF A TRACKING TOTAL STATION AS A POSITION REFERENCE FOR DYNAMIC GNSS ACCURACY TESTING
    Sama, M. P.
    Stombaugh, T. S.
    APPLIED ENGINEERING IN AGRICULTURE, 2014, 30 (04) : 557 - 563
  • [40] Accuracy Evaluation and Comparative Analysis of Four Major GNSS Broadcast Ephemeris
    Zhang X.
    Liu C.
    Zhang F.
    Wu Q.
    Hu X.
    Wuhan Daxue Xuebao (Xinxi Kexue Ban)/Geomatics and Information Science of Wuhan University, 2022, 47 (02): : 208 - 218