Conceptual objections to the Bohr atomic theory - do electrons have a "free will" ?

被引:3
|
作者
Kragh, Helge [1 ]
机构
[1] Aarhus Univ, Ctr Sci Studies, DK-8000 Aarhus, Denmark
来源
EUROPEAN PHYSICAL JOURNAL H | 2011年 / 36卷 / 03期
关键词
MODEL; CONSTITUTION; RADIATION; HYDROGEN; SPECTRA;
D O I
10.1140/epjh/e2011-20031-x
中图分类号
N09 [自然科学史]; B [哲学、宗教];
学科分类号
01 ; 0101 ; 010108 ; 060207 ; 060305 ; 0712 ;
摘要
The atomic model introduced by Bohr in 1913 dominated the development of the old quantum theory. Its main features, such as the radiationless stationary states and the discontinuous quantum jumps between the states, were hard to swallow for contemporary physicists. While acknowledging the empirical power of the theory, many scientists criticized its foundation or looked for ways to reconcile it with classical physics. Among the chief critics were A. Crehore, J.J. Thomson, E. Gehrcke and J. Stark. This paper examines from a historical perspective the conceptual objections to Bohr's atom, in particular the stationary states (where electrodynamics was annulled by fiat) and the mysterious, apparently teleological quantum jumps. Although few of the critics played a constructive role in the development of the old quantum theory, a history neglecting their presence would be incomplete and distorted.
引用
收藏
页码:327 / 352
页数:26
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [21] Embedding of the Atomic Theory of Subsets of Free Semigroups to the Atomic Theory of Subsets of Free Monoids
    Konstantinovskiy, B. O.
    Kholodilov, F. D.
    MOSCOW UNIVERSITY MATHEMATICS BULLETIN, 2022, 77 (02) : 108 - 111
  • [22] Embedding of the Atomic Theory of Subsets of Free Semigroups to the Atomic Theory of Subsets of Free Monoids
    B. O. Konstantinovskiy
    F. D. Kholodilov
    Moscow University Mathematics Bulletin, 2022, 77 : 108 - 111
  • [23] Point-of-Care Blood Tests: Do Indian Villagers Have Cultural Objections?
    Vicziany, Marika
    Hardikar, Jaideep
    FRONTIERS IN CHEMISTRY, 2018, 6
  • [24] DO NUCLEONS AND ELECTRONS HAVE ELECTRIC DIPOLE MOMENTS
    不详
    PHYSICS TODAY, 1968, 21 (03) : 71 - &
  • [25] The theory of free electrons in metals.
    von Hauer, F
    PHYSIKALISCHE ZEITSCHRIFT, 1917, 18 : 149 - 151
  • [26] THE THEORY OF LASERS ON FREE-ELECTRONS
    PONOMARYOV, IV
    KHAPAYEV, AM
    IZVESTIYA VYSSHIKH UCHEBNYKH ZAVEDENII FIZIKA, 1986, 29 (07): : 83 - 87
  • [27] On theory of metal free electrons diamagnetism
    Vonsovskiy, SV
    Svirskiy, MS
    FIZIKA METALLOV I METALLOVEDENIE, 1996, 82 (03): : 64 - 69
  • [28] Do fruit flies have free will?
    Iredale, Mathew
    Midgley, Mary
    TPM-THE PHILOSOPHERS MAGAZINE, 2011, (53): : 32 - 45
  • [29] Do we have free will.
    Libet, B
    FASEB JOURNAL, 1998, 12 (04): : A137 - A137
  • [30] Do group agents have free will?
    List, Christian
    INQUIRY-AN INTERDISCIPLINARY JOURNAL OF PHILOSOPHY, 2025, 68 (03): : 1021 - 1048