Fear of cancer recurrence is common among breast cancer (BC) survivors. We investigated methods of diagnosing recurrence and their association with survival. Metastatic diagnoses were most commonly made by patient-reported symptoms, and there was no survival difference by diagnostic method, which, we hope, will ease the anxiety experienced by BC patients. Background: Breast cancer (BC) patients undergoing surveillance often fear recurrence. Given that routine imaging is not recommended, recognizing metastatic disease early requires a knowledge of recurrence patterns. The aimof this study was to analyze the most common presentations of metastatic disease. Patients and Methods: A retrospective review was conducted of patients who were initially diagnosed with early-stage BC and who later developed metastatic disease. Data collected included method of metastatic disease diagnosis, types of symptoms at diagnosis, and survival. Chi-square tests as well as logistic and Cox regression models were used. Results: Metastatic diagnoses were made from reported symptoms in 77.6% of patients, clinical examination in 3.2%, and 7.8% incidentally on imaging. Among those with symptoms, musculoskeletal pain was the most common (33.7%) and was more frequently noted at scheduled (48.9%) compared to acute-care visits (26.0%, P < .01). Receptor status was associated with nervous system symptoms at metastasis (P = .01), with higher odds of nervous system symptoms in triple-negative (odds ratio = 3.02) compared to estrogen receptor/progesterone receptorepositive, HER2- cases. On multivariable analysis, initial stage (P =.03), receptor status (P <.01), age (P <.01), and time to recurrence (P <.01) were significantly associated with 10-year survival after diagnosis of metastasis, whereas the presence of symptoms was not (P =.27). Providers of BC patients undergoing surveillance should modify their threshold of suspicion for recurrence depending on the characteristics of the initial diagnosis and the symptoms subsequently reported. Conclusion: In this retrospective study, patients who presented with symptoms did not have shorter survival compared to those who were diagnosed in other ways. (C) 2019 The Author(s). Published by Elsevier Inc.