Direct numerical simulations were conducted for oscillating flow with zero time mean (reciprocating flow) in a plane channel subject to a harmonic forcing term of varying amplitude and frequency. The results confirmed the existence of four flow regimes (laminar, "disturbed laminar", intermittently turbulent, and fully turbulent) depending on the above parameters. The flow behaviour was found to depend on the complex interplay of mean and turbulence quantities, as described by the closed loop formed by the streamwise Reynolds-averaged momentum equation in conjunction with the exact transport equations for the turbulent (Reynolds) stresses. A crucial role in this loop appeared to be played by the different time response of the mean flow to the applied forcing at different cross-stream locations, due to the laminar and turbulent diffusion of momentum from the walls and causing characteristic distortions of the cross-stream mean velocity profiles at different phases (i.e. acceleration vs. deceleration). The intrinsic inertia of turbulence quantities themselves played only a minor role, as confirmed by the fact that, in a broad range of conditions, turbulent stresses were roughly in phase with the respective production and dissipation terms. The structure of turbulence was found to depend largely on the instantaneous mean velocity profile, as confirmed by "frozen velocity" simulations. (C) 2011 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.