Textual borrowing in science summaries: upper-elementary and middle school students learning to write the language of science

被引:3
|
作者
Qin, Wenjuan [1 ]
Uccelli, Paola [2 ]
机构
[1] Fudan Univ, Coll Foreign Languages & Literature, Liberal Arts Bldg 431,220 Handan Rd, Shanghai 200433, Peoples R China
[2] Harvard Univ, Grad Sch Educ, Cambridge, MA 02138 USA
关键词
Textual borrowing; Summary writing; Academic language; The language of science; Elementary school; Middle school; PLAGIARISM; L1;
D O I
10.1007/s11145-021-10155-4
中图分类号
G40 [教育学];
学科分类号
040101 ; 120403 ;
摘要
In writing science summaries, student writers frequently borrow language fragments from source texts. While taking a text's ideas verbatim is commonly considered a failure in writers' expected use of their own words or even plagiarism, imitating "linguistic chunks" from skilled speakers is also an effective practice in language development. This study argues for the need to investigate textual borrowing (TB) from a developmental perspective. A total of 956 U.S. upper-elementary and middle school L1 students were administered a reading comprehension test, a written summary task, and a receptive academic language assessment. Multiple indices were generated to capture TB frequency, length, and one particular function of TB (i.e., definitions). Results revealed that 68% of summaries contained at least one incidence of TB. As expected, both TB frequency and length were negatively associated with reading comprehension and academic language skills. However, students in higher grades demonstrated significantly more and longer TB in comparison to their younger counterparts when summarizing the same passage. In addition, the frequency of borrowed word strings and the ratio of definitional borrowing were positively associated with summary writing quality, and the latter association was found to be stronger for students with higher academic language skills. Implications for pedagogy and future research are discussed.
引用
收藏
页码:2505 / 2528
页数:24
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [41] Outlines for science digital competence of elementary school students
    Spernjak, Andreja
    Sorgo, Andrej
    2018 41ST INTERNATIONAL CONVENTION ON INFORMATION AND COMMUNICATION TECHNOLOGY, ELECTRONICS AND MICROELECTRONICS (MIPRO), 2018, : 825 - 829
  • [42] Science for kids outreach programs: College students teaching science to elementary school students and their parents
    Koehler, BG
    Park, LY
    Kaplan, LJ
    JOURNAL OF CHEMICAL EDUCATION, 1999, 76 (11) : 1505 - 1509
  • [43] AN INTERDISCIPLINARY SCIENCE FESTIVAL FOR ELEMENTARY-SCHOOL STUDENTS
    SCHULTZ, SD
    WORKING TOGETHER TO EDUCATE ABOUT THE ENVIRONMENT: 1989 JOINT CONFERENCE PROCEEDINGS, 1989, : 361 - 365
  • [44] SCIENCE ATTITUDE SCALE FOR MIDDLE SCHOOL STUDENTS
    MISITI, FL
    SHRIGLEY, RL
    HANSON, L
    SCIENCE EDUCATION, 1991, 75 (05) : 525 - 540
  • [45] Pop-Up Constructions Motivate and Reinforce Science Learning for Upper Elementary Students
    Olsen, Benjamin D.
    Zhbanova, Ksenia S.
    Parpucu, Harun
    Alkouri, Zaid
    Rule, Audrey C.
    SCIENCE ACTIVITIES-PROJECTS AND CURRICULUM IDEAS IN STEM CLASSROOMS, 2013, 50 (04): : 119 - 133
  • [46] Effect of Live Simulation on Middle School Students' Attitudes and Learning toward Science
    Chen, Ching-Huei
    Howard, Bruce
    EDUCATIONAL TECHNOLOGY & SOCIETY, 2010, 13 (01): : 133 - 139
  • [47] An Exploratory Analysis of a Middle School Science Curriculum: Implications for Students With Learning Disabilities
    Taylor, Gregory S.
    Hord, Casey
    LEARNING DISABILITIES-A MULTIDISCIPLINARY JOURNAL, 2016, 21 (02) : 1 - 13
  • [48] Effects of Game Application Science Learning on a Scientific Attitude of Middle School Students
    Kwon, Ki-Soon
    Kim, Hee-Soo
    JOURNAL OF THE KOREAN EARTH SCIENCE SOCIETY, 2009, 30 (02): : 257 - 264
  • [49] Designing for deeper learning in a blended computer science course for middle school students
    Grover, Shuchi
    Pea, Roy
    Cooper, Stephen
    COMPUTER SCIENCE EDUCATION, 2015, 25 (02) : 199 - 237
  • [50] Developing Middle School Students’ Interest in Learning Science and Geology Through Slowmation
    Reece Mills
    Louisa Tomas
    Chrystal Whiteford
    Brian Lewthwaite
    Research in Science Education, 2020, 50 : 1501 - 1520