Are ethical theories relevant for ethical leadership?

被引:31
|
作者
Dion, Michel [1 ]
机构
[1] Univ Sherbrooke, Fac Business Adm, Dept Management, Sherbrooke, PQ J1K 2R1, Canada
关键词
Ethical theories; Ethical leadership; Professional ethics; Leadership; Management styles; CHARISMATIC LEADERSHIP; VALUES;
D O I
10.1108/01437731211193098
中图分类号
C93 [管理学];
学科分类号
12 ; 1201 ; 1202 ; 120202 ;
摘要
Purpose - The aim of this study is to know if ethical theories could be connected to some leadership approaches. Design/methodology/approach - In the paper eight leadership approaches are selected: directive leadership, self-leadership, authentic leadership, transactional leadership, shared leadership, charismatic leadership, servant leadership, transformational leadership. Five western ethical theories (philosophical egoism, utilitarianism, Kantianism, ethics of virtue, ethics of responsibility) are analyzed to see to what extent their basic concepts could be connected to one or the other leadership approach. Findings - A given ethical theory (such as philosophical egoism) could he suitable to the components of various leadership approaches. Ethical leadership does not imply that a given leadership approach is reflecting only one ethical theory. Rather, ethical leadership implies that for different reasons, various leadership approaches could agree with the same ethical theory. This is what we could call the "moral flexibility of leadership approaches". Research limitations/implications - This study focuses on western ethical theories. A similar study should be undertaken for Eastern ethical theories coming from Buddhism, Hinduism, Confucianism, or Daoism. Practical implications - Some dualisms (such as Kantianism-transformational leadership, philosophical egoism-transactional leadership) do not reflect the philosophical connections between ethical theories and leadership approaches. Thus, the notion of ethical leadership would have to be redefined. In doing so, the paper reveals how a given ethical theory could be used by different kinds of leaders, and for very different reasons. Originality/value - This study will contribute to make ethical theories and ethical leadership more interconnected, in spite of the different (parallel) "conceptual universes" in which they have evolved until now.
引用
收藏
页码:4 / 24
页数:21
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [11] Ethical leadership in healthcare
    Bryden, Daniele C.
    ANAESTHESIA AND INTENSIVE CARE MEDICINE, 2024, 25 (11): : 792 - 795
  • [12] The centrality of ethical leadership
    Ehrich, Lisa C.
    Harris, Jessica
    Klenowski, Val
    Smeed, Judy
    Spina, Nerida
    JOURNAL OF EDUCATIONAL ADMINISTRATION, 2015, 53 (02) : 197 - 214
  • [13] The challenge of ethical leadership
    Fulmer, RM
    ORGANIZATIONAL DYNAMICS, 2004, 33 (03) : 307 - 317
  • [14] TESTING ETHICAL THEORIES
    STERN, K
    JOURNAL OF PHILOSOPHY, 1966, 63 (09): : 234 - 238
  • [15] Educating for ethical leadership
    Gallagher, Ann
    Tschudin, Verena
    NURSE EDUCATION TODAY, 2010, 30 (03) : 224 - 227
  • [16] Ethical dimensions of leadership
    Covrig, D
    LEADERSHIP QUARTERLY, 1998, 9 (02): : 234 - 238
  • [17] Ethical Leadership: A Primer
    Kalf, Wouter
    ETHICAL PERSPECTIVES, 2019, 26 (03) : 543 - 546
  • [18] CONTEMPORARY ETHICAL THEORIES
    不详
    SOCIOLOGY AND SOCIAL RESEARCH, 1950, 35 (02): : 150 - 150
  • [19] THE ETHICAL IMPERATIVES OF THEORIES
    CRAWFORD, DJ
    HEALTH PHYSICS, 1981, 40 (02): : 264 - 264
  • [20] The case for ethical leadership
    Seidman, D
    ACADEMY OF MANAGEMENT EXECUTIVE, 2004, 18 (02): : 134 - 138