Robust, atlas-free, automatic segmentation of brain MRI in health and disease

Background: Brain-and lesion-volumes derived from magnetic resonance images (MRI) serve as important imaging markers of disease progression in neurodegenerative diseases and aging. While manual segmentation of these volumes is both tedious and impractical in large cohorts of subjects, automated segmentation methods often fail in accurate segmentation of brains with severe atrophy or high lesion loads. The purpose of this study was to develop an atlas-free brain Classification using DErivative-based Features (C-DEF), which utilizes all scans that may be acquired during the course of a routine MRI study at any center. Methods: Proton-density, T-2-weighted, T-1-weighted, brain-free water, 3D FLAIR, 3D T-2-weighted, and 3D T-2*-weighted images, collected routinely on patients with neuroinflammatory diseases at the NIH, were used to optimize the C-DEF algorithm on healthy volunteers and HIV + subjects (cohort 1). First, manually marked lesions and eroded FreeSurfer brain segmentation masks (compiled into gray and white matter, globus pallidus, CSF labels) were used in training. Next, the optimized C-DEF was applied on a separate cohort of HIV thorn subjects (cohort two), and the results were compared with that of FreeSurfer and Lesion-TOADS. Finally, C-DEF segmentation was evaluated on subjects clinically diagnosed with various other neurological diseases (cohort three). Results: C-DEF algorithm was optimized using leave-one-out cross validation on five healthy subjects (age 36 +/- 11 years), and five subjects infected with HIV (age 57 +/- 2.6 years) in cohort one. The optimized C-DEF algorithm outperformed FreeSurfer and Lesion-TOADS segmentation in 49 other subjects infected with HIV (cohort two, age 54 +/- 6 years) in qualitative and quantitative comparisons. Although trained only on HIV brains, sensitivity to detect lesions using C-DEF increased by 45% in HTLV-I-associated myelopathy/tropical spastic paraparesis (n = 5; age 58 +/- 7 years), 33% in multiple sclerosis (n = 5; 42 +/- 9 years old), and 4% in subjects with polymorphism of the cytotoxic T-lymphocyte-associated protein 4 gene (n = 5; age 24 +/- 12 years) compared to Lesion-TOADS. Conclusion: C-DEF outperformed other segmentation algorithms in the various neurological diseases explored herein, especially in lesion segmentation. While the results reported are from routine images acquired at the NIH, the algorithm can be easily trained and optimized for any set of contrasts and protocols for wider application. We are currently exploring various technical aspects of optimal implementation of CDEF in a clinical setting and evaluating a larger cohort of patients with other neurological diseases. Improving the accuracy of brain segmentation methodology will help better understand the relationship of imaging abnormalities to clinical and neuropsychological markers in disease.