Is there a unique moral status of human DNA that prevents patenting?

被引:4
|
作者
Hoedemaekers, R
Dekkers, W
机构
关键词
D O I
10.1353/ken.2001.0030
中图分类号
B82 [伦理学(道德学)];
学科分类号
摘要
The gene patenting debate, which proved to be a focal point for divergent moral concerns about recent developments in genome research and biotechnology, has revealed that the moral status of DNA is not clear. One of the arguments used to stop undesirable developments was that DNA possesses a unique status, which renders it unfit for patenting. This paper investigates the allegedly unique (moral) status of genetic material and the information it holds from different perspectives. Several properties of DNA prove to be unique. We examine the relevance of these for patentability of genes and conclude that only the unique symbolic meaning of DNA is a relevant factor, which should be taken into account but weighed against other interests involved.
引用
收藏
页码:359 / 386
页数:28
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [21] Patenting DNA sequences
    Cheryl H. Agris
    Nature Biotechnology, 1998, 16 : 877 - 877
  • [22] Patenting of human DNA sequences - Implications for prenatal genetic testing
    Donahue, J
    BRANDEIS JOURNAL OF FAMILY LAW, VOL 36, NO 2, SPRING ISSUE - 1997-98, 1998, : 267 - 283
  • [23] Human Nature and Moral Status in Bioethics
    Shea, Matthew
    JOURNAL OF MEDICINE AND PHILOSOPHY, 2018, 43 (02): : 115 - 131
  • [24] The moral status of embryonic human life
    Johnson, MF
    WHAT IS MAN O LORD? THE HUMAN PERSON IN A BIOTECH AGE, 2002, : 181 - 198
  • [25] HUMAN DIGNITY AS HIGH MORAL STATUS
    Toscano, Manuel
    ATELIERS DE L ETHIQUE-THE ETHICS FORUM, 2011, 6 (02): : 4 - 25
  • [26] The moral and legal status of the human embryo
    Beyleveld, D
    IN VITRO FERTILISATION IN THE 1990S: TOWARDS A MEDICAL, SOCIAL AND ETHICAL EVALUATION, 1998, : 247 - 260
  • [27] Transhumanism, Human Dignity, and Moral Status
    Sandler, Ronald
    Basl, John
    AMERICAN JOURNAL OF BIOETHICS, 2010, 10 (07): : 63 - 66
  • [28] Moral uncertainty and the moral status of early human life.
    Selgelid M.J.
    Monash Bioethics Review, 2012, 30 (1) : 52 - 57
  • [29] The moral status of human embryo-like structures: potentiality matters? The moral status of human synthetic embryos
    Sawai, Tsutomu
    Minakawa, Tomohiro
    Pugh, Jonathan
    Akatsuka, Kyoko
    Yamashita, Jun K.
    Fujita, Misao
    EMBO REPORTS, 2020, 21 (08)
  • [30] To patent or not to patent: dissecting moral disharmony in the context of human embryonic stem cell patenting
    Shelke, Atmaram
    Arya, Sujata
    Prasad, Sachchidanand
    Sharma, Padmakshi
    COGENT SOCIAL SCIENCES, 2025, 11 (01):