Wedge resection versus lobectomy for T1NO non-small cell lung cancer

被引:0
|
作者
Stefani, A. [1 ]
Nesci, J. [1 ]
Casali, C. [1 ]
Morandi, U. [1 ]
机构
[1] Modena & Reggio Emilia Univ, Unit Thorac Surg, Modena, Italy
关键词
Carcinoma; non-small-cell lung Surgical procedures; operative; Lobectomy; SUBLOBAR RESECTION; SURVIVAL; SEGMENTECTOMY; LYMPHADENECTOMY; OUTCOMES; MARGIN; TRIAL; CT;
D O I
暂无
中图分类号
R61 [外科手术学];
学科分类号
摘要
Aim. Advances in imaging techniques and screening protocols can detect more small lung cancers. Controversy exists regarding surgical management of these small tumors. Methods. Records and long-term outcome of all patients with T1NO (<= 2 cm) non-small cell lung cancer undergoing wedge resection with curative intent from 1996 through 2010 were retrospectively reviewed. Those patients were compared with a group of patients treated with lobectomy during the same period and for a disease at the same stage. Sub lobar resections were performed in compromised patients in all cases. Results. The study included 206 patients: 82 received wedge resection, 124 lobectomy. Morbidity and mortality were similar between the two groups. Locoregional recurrence rate was significantly higher for wedge resection compared with lobectomy (22% versus 8% respectively), cancer-specific survival and disease-free survival were significantly poorer for wedge resection with respect to lobectomy: 5-year survival of 74% versus 85% respectively, 5-year disease-free survival of 62% versus 77%. The type of operation resulted as an independent prognostic factor of cancer-specific survival. Conclusions. We found poorer outcome for wedge resection compared to lobectomy. We believe that caution should be used when suggesting the use of wedge resection as intentional limited resection for patients with small non-small cell lung cancer who may otherwise tolerate lobectomy. Two randomized trials comparing limited resection and lobectomy are ongoing in Japan and in United States: they will better clarify the role of limited resection, especially segmentectomy, in the treatment of T1aNO tumors. Wedge resection may remain a valid option for compromised patients.
引用
收藏
页码:489 / 498
页数:10
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [31] Lobectomy, segmentectomy, or wedge resection for peripheral clinical T1aN0 non-small cell lung cancer: A post hoc analysis of CALGB 140503 (Alliance)
    Altorki, Nasser
    Wang, Xiaofei
    Damman, Bryce
    Mentlick, Jennifer
    Landreneau, Rodney
    Wigle, Dennis
    Jones, David R.
    Conti, Massimo
    Ashrafi, Ahmad S.
    Liberman, Moishe
    de Perrot, Marc
    Mitchell, John D.
    Keenan, Robert
    Bauer, Thomas
    Miller, Daniel
    Stinchcombe, Thomas E.
    JOURNAL OF THORACIC AND CARDIOVASCULAR SURGERY, 2024, 167 (01): : 338 - +
  • [32] Wedge resection before lobectomy for patients with T1N0M0 non-small cell lung cancer: a propensity score matching analysis
    Zeng, Yuan
    Huang, Ying
    Fu, Junhui
    Xu, Ke
    Liang, Wenhua
    Cui, Fei
    Hao, Zhexue
    Li, Xukai
    Xing, Tuo
    He, Jianxing
    Liu, Jun
    ANNALS OF TRANSLATIONAL MEDICINE, 2022, 10 (09)
  • [33] Comparison of Wedge Versus Lobar Resection for Stage 1 Non-Small Cell Lung Cancer: A SEER-Medicare Analysis
    Tuminello, Stephanie
    Wolf, Andrea
    Taioli, Emanuela
    Flores, Raja
    ANNALS OF THORACIC SURGERY, 2018, 106 (04): : 1260 - +
  • [34] Segmentectomy Versus Wedge Resection for Non-Small Cell Lung Cancer in High-Risk Operable Patients
    Kent, Michael
    Landreneau, Rodney
    Mandrekar, Sumithra
    Hillman, Shauna
    Nichols, Francis
    Jones, David
    Starnes, Sandra
    Tan, Angelina
    Putnam, Joe
    Meyers, Brian
    Daly, Benedict
    Fernando, Hiran C.
    ANNALS OF THORACIC SURGERY, 2013, 96 (05): : 1747 - 1755
  • [35] Segmentectomy versus wedge resection for radiological solid predominant and low metabolic non-small cell lung cancer
    Kagimoto, Atsushi
    Tsutani, Yasuhiro
    Mimae, Takahiro
    Miyata, Yoshihiro
    Okada, Morihito
    INTERACTIVE CARDIOVASCULAR AND THORACIC SURGERY, 2022, 34 (05) : 814 - 821
  • [36] Segmentectomy Versus Wedge Resection for Stage I Non-Small Cell Lung Cancer: A Meta-analysis
    Zhang, Haihua
    Liu, Chen
    Tan, Zhijun
    Zhang, Tao
    JOURNAL OF SURGICAL RESEARCH, 2019, 243 : 371 - 379
  • [37] Wedge resection versus lobectomy in T1 lung cancer patients: a propensity matched analysis
    Moon, Robert J.
    Taylor, Rebecca
    Miklavc, Pika
    Mehdi, Syed B.
    Grant, Stuart W.
    Bittar, Mohamad Nidal
    JOURNAL OF CARDIOTHORACIC SURGERY, 2023, 18 (01)
  • [38] Wedge resection versus lobectomy in T1 lung cancer patients: a propensity matched analysis
    Robert J Moon
    Rebecca Taylor
    Pika Miklavc
    Syed B Mehdi
    Stuart W Grant
    Mohamad Nidal Bittar
    Journal of Cardiothoracic Surgery, 18
  • [39] Comparison of outcomes of sleeve lobectomy for lung carcinoid versus non-small cell lung cancer
    Lang, P.
    Singh, S.
    Murray, J.
    Kirk, A.
    LUNG CANCER, 2016, 91 : S65 - S66
  • [40] Wedge Resection vs Segmentectomy for Patients with T1A N0 Non-Small Cell Lung Cancer
    Yang, Chi-Fu J.
    Chan, Derek Y.
    Gulack, Brian C.
    Speicher, Paul J.
    Onaitis, Mark W.
    Tong, Betty C.
    D'Amico, Thomas A.
    Harpole, David
    Berry, Mark F.
    Hartwig, Matthew G.
    JOURNAL OF THORACIC ONCOLOGY, 2015, 10 (09) : S242 - S242