Comparison of the Eulerian and Lagrangian approaches in studying the flow pattern and heat transfer in a separated axisymmetric turbulent gas-droplet flow

The Eulerian and Lagrangian approaches are used to perform a numerical study of the disperse phase dynamics, turbulence, and heat transfer in a turbulent gas-droplet flow in a tube with sudden expansion with the following ranges of two-phase flow parameters: initial droplet size d (1) = 0-200 A mu m and mass fraction of droplets M (L1) = 0-0.1. The main difference between the Eulerian and Lagrangian approaches is the difference in the predictions of the droplet mass fraction: the Eulerian approach predicts a smaller value of M (L) both in the recirculation region and in the flow core (the difference reaches 15-20%). It is demonstrated that the disperse phase mass fraction calculated by the Lagrangian approach agrees better with measured data than the corresponding value predicted by the Eulerian approach.