Are Informal and Semi-formal Hierarchical Lists Justified?

被引:2
|
作者
de Shalit, Avner [1 ]
机构
[1] Hebrew Univ Jerusalem, Dept Polit Sci, Mt Scopus, IL-91905 Jerusalem, Israel
关键词
Hierarchies; Market; Information; Daniel Bell; Wang Pei; RANKINGS;
D O I
10.1007/s40647-023-00397-7
中图分类号
C [社会科学总论];
学科分类号
03 ; 0303 ;
摘要
In their important book, Bell and Wang argue that hierarchies are here to stay, and the question moral philosophy should face is which hierarchies are morally condemnable and which are morally justifiable. They convincingly explain that hierarchies that contribute to social functioning and increase human well-being (often even benefitting those on the lower ranking of hierarchies) or hierarchies with a kind of fluid character and consist of mechanisms or rules that enable switching roles can be justified. In my paper, I wish to examine whether, according to their principles, informal and semi-formal hierarchies which are created by the market or by a firm, using an algorithm, can be justified. These hierarchies differ from the ones discussed by Bell and Wang in that they are not part of traditional or legal institutions or relationships. They are actually informal or semi-formal and are often created spontaneously by, or as a result of an aggregation of many individuals' economic exchanges. Sometimes they are publicized formally (e.g., a list of best sellers' authors, or when prizes are awarded) and sometimes they are simply a matter of the wisdom of the crowd. On the one hand hierarchies in markets are meant to (a) inform consumers and producers and (b) create a healthy competition, so, prima facie they help us and increase our well-being. In addition, they are meant to shift over time, as they depend on the quality of the producer and the product and their ability to compete with other, new, e.g., more technologically advanced, products. Therefore, on the face of it, these hierarchies could be justified according to Bell and Wang's theory. Nevertheless, I argue that there are other characteristics of these hierarchies which make them condemnable according to the theory and that the cons outweigh the pros. These are: (1) Market hierarchies are based on category mistakes; (2) Market hierarchies are likely to be deceptive-they might inform consumers but with deceptive and often irrelevant information; (3) Market hierarchies are not genuinely flexible and therefore work against the principle of shifting roles which Bell and Wang put forward.
引用
收藏
页数:15
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [31] A SEMI-FORMAL EXPLICATION OF PARSONS,TALCOTT THEORY OF ACTION
    HAYES, AC
    SOCIOLOGICAL INQUIRY, 1980, 50 (01) : 39 - 56
  • [32] On Dynamic Switching of Navigation for Semi-Formal Design Validation
    Parikh, Ankur
    Hsiao, Michael S.
    HLDVT: 2008 IEEE INTERNATIONAL HIGH LEVEL DESIGN VALIDATION AND TEST WORKSHOP, PROCEEDINGS, 2008, : 41 - 48
  • [33] Semi-formal design of reliable mesh generation systems
    ElSheikh, AH
    Smith, S
    Chidiac, SE
    ADVANCES IN ENGINEERING SOFTWARE, 2004, 35 (12) : 827 - 841
  • [34] CyberGSN: A Semi-formal Language for Specifying Safety Cases
    Beyene, Tewodros A.
    Carlan, Carmen
    51ST ANNUAL IEEE/IFIP INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE ON DEPENDABLE SYSTEMS AND NETWORKS (DSN-W 2021), 2021, : 63 - 66
  • [35] Semi-formal method for security policies and design specifications
    Deng H.
    Shi H.
    Zhang B.
    Yang Y.
    Liu H.
    2017, Tsinghua University (57): : 695 - 701
  • [36] Semi-formal verification of VHDL-AMS descriptions
    Salem, A
    2002 IEEE INTERNATIONAL SYMPOSIUM ON CIRCUITS AND SYSTEMS, VOL V, PROCEEDINGS, 2002, : 333 - 336
  • [37] Validating semi-formal specifications of interactors as design representations
    Markopoulos, P
    Papatzanis, G
    Johnson, P
    Rowson, J
    DESIGN, SPECIFICATION AND VERIFICATION OF INTERACTIVE SYSTEMS'98, 1998, : 102 - 116
  • [38] Semi-formal test generation for a block of industrial DSP
    Dushina, J
    Benjamin, M
    Geist, D
    19TH IEEE VLSI TEST SYMPOSIUM, PROCEEDINGS, 2001, : 131 - 136
  • [39] Requirements interaction detection using semi-formal methods
    Shehata, M
    Eberlein, A
    ECBS 2003: 10TH IEEE INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE AND WORKSHOP ON THE ENGINEERING OF COMPUTER-BASED SYSTEMS, PROCEEDINGS, 2003, : 224 - 232
  • [40] Semi-formal verification of memory systems by symbolic simulation
    Abu-Haimed, H
    Berezin, S
    Dill, DL
    CORRECT HARDWARE DESIGN AND VERIFICATION METHODS, PROCEEDINGS, 2003, 2860 : 158 - 163