Phasor and EMT models of grid-following and grid-forming converters for short-circuit simulations

Phasor models have been widely used in short-circuit simulations, in which system operators verify the behaviour of the grid over thousands of different contingencies. However, it is still unclear if phasor models can still be used in fault studies in modern or future power grids dominated by renewable generation with power electronics and converters. Therefore, this paper analyses the suitability of phasor models to simulate short-circuit transients in grids with grid-following (GFL) and grid-forming (GFM) voltage-source converters (VSC). Phasor models of GFL and GFM were developed and tested in two test systems, one with 50% of converters in the generation mix and another powered 100% by converters. Asymmetrical and symmetrical faults were applied at different points of the systems and key variables were used to compare the phasor models against EMT models during the transients. The results showed that, despite neglecting transients in the grid, phasor models could be used in a preliminary stage of short-circuit studies as it was capable of tracking the steady-state value of almost all variables analysed. In this case, detailed EMT simulations, although necessary, would be used only at more advanced stages of the studies.