Confidence Across Cleavage: The Swiss Rural-Urban Divide, Place-Based Identity and Political Trust

被引:3
|
作者
Zumbrunn, Alina [1 ]
机构
[1] Univ Bern, Inst Polit Sci, Fabrikstr 8, CH-3012 Bern, Switzerland
关键词
Place-based identity; Political trust; Rural-urban divide; Suburbs; CONTINUUM; SWITZERLAND; RELEVANCE; VOTE;
D O I
10.1111/spsr.12586
中图分类号
D0 [政治学、政治理论];
学科分类号
0302 ; 030201 ;
摘要
Since political trust is crucial to the survival of political systems, securing its high levels is essential. While Switzerland exhibits a large rural-urban divide in direct democratic votes, it has not yet been researched whether such a divide also exists with regard to political trust. In my investigation of the Swiss rural-urban divide in political trust, I bring in place as a social identity and evaluate whether the rural-urban divide is contingent upon place-based identity. I employ OLS regression models using original survey data from 2022 with about 4,000 respondents. Results reveal a significant but irrelevantly small rural-urban difference in political trust. However, when interacting place-based identity with place of living, I find that identity inverts the rural-urban divide. When place-based identity is low, rural residents exhibit higher levels of political trust than urban residents, but when place-based identity is high, trust is higher in urban than in rural places. Politisches Vertrauen ist fur das uberleben politischer Systeme entscheidend. In der Schweiz zeigt sich bei den direktdemokratischen Abstimmungen ein grosser Land-Stadt-Graben; es ist aber noch nicht erforscht, ob ein solcher Graben auch bei politischem Vertrauen besteht. In dieser Untersuchung des Schweizer Land-Stadt-Grabens bei politischem Vertrauen wird der Ort als soziale Identitat miteinbezogen und evaluiert, ob der Land-Stadt-Graben von der ortsbezogenen Identitat abhangig ist. Ich verwende OLS-Regressionsmodelle und Original-Umfragedaten aus dem Jahr 2022 mit rund 4.000 Befragten. Die Ergebnisse zeigen einen signifikanten, aber unerheblich kleinen Unterschied zwischen Stadt und Land in Bezug auf politisches Vertrauen. Bei einer Interaktion zwischen ortsbezogener Identitat und Wohnort zeigt sich, dass die Identitat den Effekt des Land-Stadt-Grabens umkehrt. Wenn ortsbezogene Identitat schwach ausgepragt ist, haben Landbewohner ein hoheres Mass an politischem Vertrauen als Stadtbewohner; wenn aber die ortsbezogene Identitat stark ausgepragt ist, ist das Vertrauen in der Stadt hoher als auf dem Land. La confiance politique est cruciale pour la survie des systemes politiques. La Suisse presente un fosse villes-campagnes dans les votes democratiques directs, mais aucune recherche n'a ete effectuee pour savoir si une telle difference existe aussi concernant la confiance politique. Dans cette etude, je considere le lieu comme une identite sociale et j'evalue si le fosse villes-campagnes depend de l'identite basee sur le lieu. J'utilise des modeles de regression OLS a partir de donnees d'enquete originales datant de 2022 et comprenant environ 4 000 repondants. Les resultats revelent un fosse villes-campagnes significatif mais insignifiant. Cependant, en faisant interagir l'identite fondee sur le lieu avec le lieu de residence, l'identite inverse l'effet du fosse. Lorsque l'identite fondee sur le lieu de residence est faible, les residents ruraux affichent des niveaux de confiance plus eleves que les residents urbains, mais lorsque l'identite est forte, la confiance est plus forte dans les zones urbaines. Siccome la fiducia politica e cruciale per la sopravvivenza dei sistemi politici, e importante fare in modo che essa si situi a livelli elevati. Sebbene la Svizzera conosca un divario citta-campagna significativo nelle votazioni popolari, finora non e stata studiata l'esistenza di un tale divario in ambito della fiducia politica. Nella mia analisi del divario citta-campagna in Svizzera ho considerato il luogo come identita sociale e esaminato in quale misura tale divario sia influenzato dall'identita legata al luogo. Usando modelli di regressione OLS e dati originali del 2022 con 4000 partecipanti, i risultati dell'analisi rivelano che la differenza fra citta e campagna relativa alla fiducia politica e statisticamente significativa ma di fatto trascurabile. Tuttavia, quando si fa interagire l'identita legata al luogo con il luogo di residenza, si scopre che questa forma di identita inverte il divario citta-campagna. Se e poco pronunciata, il livello di fiducia politica e maggiore fra gli abitanti delle aree rurali rispetto a quelli delle citta, ma quando e piu forte, la fiducia politica e maggiore nelle aree urbane rispetto a quelle rurali.
引用
收藏
页码:46 / 65
页数:20
相关论文
共 37 条
  • [31] Does increased migration affect the rural-urban divide in suicide? A register-based repeated cohort study in Sweden from 1991 to 2015
    Kanamori, Mariko
    Kondo, Naoki
    Juarez, Sol P.
    Cederstrom, Agneta
    Stickley, Andrew
    Rostila, Mikael
    POPULATION SPACE AND PLACE, 2022, 28 (01)
  • [32] Middle years students' engagement with science in rural and urban communities in Australia: exploring science capital, place-based knowledges and familial relationships
    Stahl, Garth
    Scholes, Laura
    McDonald, Sarah
    Lunn, Jo
    PEDAGOGY CULTURE AND SOCIETY, 2021, 29 (01): : 43 - 60
  • [33] Bridging the rural-urban divide in sanitation with a cluster-based approach to faecal sludge management: a case study from Dhenkanal district in Odisha, India
    Saxena, Shipra
    Chouhan, Narendra Singh
    Mojumdar, Sujoy
    Nielsen, Monika Oledzka
    Manchikanti, Swathi
    Mukherjee, Anindita
    Agarwal, Neha
    Rani, Megha
    Dutta, Anwesa
    Vignesh, Rajendran
    Walters, Jeffrey P.
    H2OPEN JOURNAL, 2022, : 549 - 566
  • [34] Can place-based policies reduce urban-rural income inequality? Evidence from China's Old Revolutionary Development Program based on county-level data
    Pan, Dan
    Fang, Peilin
    Chen, Shengdong
    ECONOMIC RESEARCH-EKONOMSKA ISTRAZIVANJA, 2022,
  • [35] The production of identity of new urban developments through place-based social big data: the growth of the Madrid metropolitan area during the real estate bubble (1990-2012)
    Carpio-Pinedo, Jose
    Lopez-Baeza, Jesus
    EURE-REVISTA LATINOAMERICANA DE ESTUDIOS URBANO REGIONALES, 2021, 47 (140): : 5 - 28
  • [36] Disparities in Access to Opioid Treatment Programs and Office-Based Buprenorphine Treatment Across the Rural-Urban and Area Deprivation Continua: A US Nationwide Small Area Analysis
    Amiri, Solmaz
    McDonell, Michael G.
    Denney, Justin T.
    Buchwald, Dedra
    Amram, Ofer
    VALUE IN HEALTH, 2021, 24 (02) : 188 - 195
  • [37] Nitrate pollution source apportionment, uncertainty and sensitivity analysis across a rural-urban river network based on δ15N/δ18O-NO3- isotopes and SIAR modeling
    Ji, Xiaoliang
    Shu, Lielin
    Chen, Wenli
    Chen, Zheng
    Shang, Xu
    Yang, Yue
    Dahlgren, Randy A.
    Zhang, Minghua
    JOURNAL OF HAZARDOUS MATERIALS, 2022, 438