Structural explanations: impossibilities vs failures

被引:0
|
作者
Barrantes, Manuel [1 ]
机构
[1] Calif State Univ Sacramento, 3022 Mendocino Hall, Sacramento, CA 95819 USA
关键词
Scientific explanation; Structural explanation; Non-causal explanation; Mathematical explanation; MATHEMATICAL EXPLANATIONS;
D O I
10.1007/s11229-023-04121-6
中图分类号
N09 [自然科学史]; B [哲学、宗教];
学科分类号
01 ; 0101 ; 010108 ; 060207 ; 060305 ; 0712 ;
摘要
The bridges of Konigsberg case has been widely cited in recent philosophical discussions on scientific explanation as a potential example of a structural explanation of a physical phenomenon. However, when discussing this case, different authors have focused on two different versions, depending on what they take the explanandum to be. In one version, the explanandum is the failure of a given individual in performing an Eulerian walk over the bridge system. In the other version, the explanandum is the impossibility of performing an Eulerian walk over the bridges. The goal of this paper is to show that only the latter version amounts to a real case of a structural explanation. I will also suggest how to fix the first version, and show how my remarks apply to other purported cases of structural explanations.
引用
收藏
页数:15
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [21] Psychological vs. biological explanations of behavior
    Dretske, F
    BEHAVIOR AND PHILOSOPHY, 2004, 32 (01) : 167 - 177
  • [22] Meaningful Explanations vs Scientific Causality Reply
    Lyketsos, Constantine G.
    Chisolm, Margaret S.
    JAMA-JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN MEDICAL ASSOCIATION, 2009, 302 (21): : 2320 - 2321
  • [23] Monopathogenic vs multipathogenic explanations of pemphigus pathophysiology
    Ahmed, A. Razzaque
    Carrozzo, Marco
    Caux, Frederic
    Cirillo, Nicola
    Dmochowski, Marian
    Espana Alonso, Agustin
    Gniadecki, Robert
    Hertl, Michael
    Lopez-Zabalza, Maria J.
    Lotti, Roberta
    Pincelli, Carlo
    Pittelkow, Mark
    Schmidt, Enno
    Sinha, Animesh A.
    Sprecher, Eli
    Grando, Sergei A.
    EXPERIMENTAL DERMATOLOGY, 2016, 25 (11) : 839 - 846
  • [24] INNOVATIVE CLUSTERS AND PUBLIC ADMINISTRATION: MARKET FAILURES VS GOVERNMENT FAILURES
    Rozanova, N. M.
    Kostenko, E. D.
    TERRA ECONOMICUS, 2014, 12 (01): : 41 - 52
  • [25] FASTENER FAILURES VS PRODUCT LIABILITY
    GRAVES, FE
    AGRICULTURAL ENGINEERING, 1982, 63 (03): : 12 - 13
  • [26] Structural explanations and norms: comments on Haslanger
    Thomasson, Amie L.
    PHILOSOPHICAL STUDIES, 2016, 173 (01) : 131 - 139
  • [27] On structural accounts of model-explanations
    Martin King
    Synthese, 2016, 193 : 2761 - 2778
  • [28] A modest proposal for interpreting structural explanations
    Thalos, M
    BRITISH JOURNAL FOR THE PHILOSOPHY OF SCIENCE, 1998, 49 (02): : 279 - 295
  • [29] Structural explanations and norms: comments on Haslanger
    Amie L. Thomasson
    Philosophical Studies, 2016, 173 : 131 - 139
  • [30] On structural accounts of model-explanations
    King, Martin
    SYNTHESE, 2016, 193 (09) : 2761 - 2778