Computer-assisted periodontal classification vs manual classification among dental students: a comparative pilot study

被引:0
|
作者
Meir, Haya [1 ]
Miller, Hadar [2 ]
Saminsky, Michael [1 ]
Huang, Yiying [3 ]
Levin, Liran [3 ]
Slutzkey, Gil [1 ,4 ]
机构
[1] Tel Aviv Univ, Sackler Med Fac, Goldschleger Sch Dent Med, Dept Periodontol & Dent Implantol, Tel Aviv, Israel
[2] Univ Haifa, Informat Syst Dept, Haifa, Israel
[3] Univ Alberta, Fac Med & Dent, Edmonton, AB, Canada
[4] Tel Aviv Univ, Goldshcleger Sch Dent Med, Sackler Fac Med, Klachkin 5, Tel Aviv, Israel
来源
QUINTESSENCE INTERNATIONAL | 2023年 / 54卷 / 10期
关键词
classification; computer assisted; periodontal; students;
D O I
10.3290/j.qi.b4225983
中图分类号
R78 [口腔科学];
学科分类号
1003 ;
摘要
Objective: The objective of the study was to assess whether computer-assisted periodontal diagnosis can improve the accuracy and homogeneity of classification results obtained by dental students using the 2017 classification of periodontal diseases. Method and materials: All final year predoctoral dental students from two dental schools were invited to participate in the study. Participants who volunteered for the study were randomly div ided into two groups for digital or manual diagnosis, and each participant classified 48 cases. A group of three experienced periodontists provided the reference or gold standard diagnosis. Results: Overall, 27 students completed the evaluation of all cases; 14 students comprised the digital application group and 13 the manual group. The accuracy of the classification results compared with the gold standard committee was 82% for the digital group com-pared to 50% of the manual group in terms of the extent of gingi-vitis; 71% vs 56% for the stage of periodontitis; 67% vs 62% for grade of periodontitis; 76% vs 63% for extent of periodontitis; and 43% vs 30% for overall diagnosis accuracy of periodontitis cases respectively. Conclusions: Computer-assisted classification using newly developed software, within the boundaries of this study, was shown to be a sensible support tool for dental practitioners to use when diagnosing periodontal disease. This digital tool can the clinicians' accuracy of diagnosis primarily in the extent and staging of periodontitis. (Quintessence Int 2023;54: 792-801; doi: 10.3290/j.qi.b4225983)
引用
收藏
页码:792 / 801
页数:10
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [21] Towards a computer-assisted classification of discourse types in the Psalms
    Montaner, LV
    BIBLE AND COMPUTER, 2002, : 189 - 208
  • [22] Towards a computer-assisted classification of discourse types in Amos
    del Barco, FJD
    BIBLE AND COMPUTER, 2002, : 283 - 293
  • [23] COMPARATIVE-ANALYSIS OF PNEUMOGRAM SCORING BY A COMPUTER-ASSISTED SYSTEM (CAPS) VS MANUAL SCORING (MS)
    SASIDHARAN, P
    MARQUEZ, E
    DIZON, E
    SRIDHAR, C
    PEDIATRIC RESEARCH, 1985, 19 (04) : A415 - A415
  • [24] COMPUTER-ASSISTED INDEPENDENT STUDY - A PILOT PROGRAM
    PRIOR, JA
    GRIESEN, JV
    FOLK, RL
    JOURNAL OF MEDICAL EDUCATION, 1970, 45 (10): : 801 - &
  • [25] Optical classification of neoplastic colorectal polyps - a computer-assisted approach (the COACH study)
    Renner, Janis
    Phlipsen, Henrik
    Haller, Bernhard
    Navarro-Avila, Fernando
    Saint-Hill-Febles, Yadira
    Mateus, Diana
    Ponchon, Thierry
    Poszler, Alexander
    Abdelhafez, Mohamed
    Schmid, Roland M.
    von Delius, Stefan
    Klare, Peter
    SCANDINAVIAN JOURNAL OF GASTROENTEROLOGY, 2018, 53 (09) : 1100 - 1106
  • [26] Students' response to traditional and computer-assisted formative feedback: A comparative case study
    Denton, Philip
    Madden, Judith
    Roberts, Matthew
    Rowe, Philip
    BRITISH JOURNAL OF EDUCATIONAL TECHNOLOGY, 2008, 39 (03) : 486 - 500
  • [27] Computer-assisted classification of contrarian claims about climate change
    Travis G. Coan
    Constantine Boussalis
    John Cook
    Mirjam O. Nanko
    Scientific Reports, 11
  • [28] Computer-assisted categorisation of patent documents in the International Patent Classification
    Fall, CJ
    Benzineb, K
    Guyot, J
    Törcsvári, A
    Fiévet, P
    PROCEEDINGS OF THE 2003 INTERNATIONAL CHEMICAL INFORMATION CONFERENCE, 2003, : 104 - 119
  • [29] Automated and Computer-Assisted Detection, Classification, and Diagnosis of Diabetic Retinopathy
    Abramoff, Michael D.
    Leng, Theodore
    Ting, Daniel S. W.
    Rhee, Kyu
    Horton, Mark B.
    Brady, Christopher J.
    Chiang, Michael F.
    TELEMEDICINE AND E-HEALTH, 2020, 26 (04) : 544 - 550
  • [30] Computer-Assisted Classification Patterns in Autoimmune Diagnostics: The AIDA Project
    Elgaaied, Amel Benammar
    Cascio, Donato
    Bruno, Salvatore
    Ciaccio, Maria Cristina
    Cipolla, Marco
    Fauci, Alessandro
    Morgante, Rossella
    Taormina, Vincenzo
    Gorgi, Yousr
    Triki, Raja Marrakchi
    Ben Ahmed, Melika
    Louzir, Hechmi
    Yalaoui, Sadok
    Imene, Sfar
    Issaoui, Yassine
    Abidi, Ahmed
    Ammar, Myriam
    Bedhiafi, Walid
    Ben Fraj, Oussama
    Bouhaha, Rym
    Hamdi, Khouloud
    Soumaya, Koudhi
    Neili, Bilel
    Asma, Gati
    Lucchese, Mariano
    Catanzaro, Maria
    Barbara, Vincenza
    Brusca, Ignazio
    Fregapane, Maria
    Amato, Gaetano
    Friscia, Giuseppe
    Neila, Trai
    Turkia, Souayeh
    Youssra, Haouami
    Rekik, Raja
    Bouokez, Hayet
    Simone, Maria Vasile
    Fauci, Francesco
    Raso, Giuseppe
    BIOMED RESEARCH INTERNATIONAL, 2016, 2016