Disparities in soil and water conservation functions among different forest types and implications for afforestation on the Loess Plateau

Afforestation is widely acknowledged as an effective approach for enhancing ecological conditions. Considering the challenging ecological environment on the Loess Plateau, prioritizing soil and water conservation functions in stands is crucial. The study aimed to ascertain the future development direction of forestry on the Loess Plateau by examining two representative forest types: planted forest (Robinia pseudoacacia pure forest and Pinus tabulaeformis pure forest), and natural secondary forest (a mixed forest of Quercus liaotungensis and Populus davidiana). The assessment centered on the soil and water conservation functions of the two forest types, encompassing the water conservation function (rainfall distribution and changes in multi-year soil moisture storage (0-200 cm)), soil conservation function (soil physicochemical properties), and understory plant diversity and stability. The results indicated that natural secondary forests outperformed planted forests in terms of water conservation function by effectively converting more precipitation into soil moisture, reducing runoff, and maintaining higher soil moisture storage. Additionally, natural secondary forests exhibited superior soil conservation functions compared to planted forests, characterized by higher soil porosity and nutrient properties. The variation in community structure between the shrub and herbaceous layers was more significant among different forests than within each forest (P < 0.05). Natural secondary forests exhibited higher understory shrub and herb biodiversity and interspecific repeatability compared to planted forests. Therefore, natural secondary forests are a more suitable forest type considering the natural conditions and silvicultural objectives of the Loess Plateau. To enhance the quality of afforestation, it is recommended to adopt near-natural planting patterns that replicate the environmental conditions of natural forests. For instance, actively creating mixed forests that emulate the tree species composition of natural forests and gradually reducing dependence on a single dominant tree species. Furthermore, the arborous and litter layers had a more direct and substantial influence on soil and water conservation functions compared to the shrub and herb layers. Foresters should prioritize regulating stand structure, such as increasing canopy variability, to enhance the water conservation function of stands. Additionally, they should actively protect the understory litter to fulfill its role in enhancing soil quality. This study provides a theoretical foundation and practical guidance for the implementation of vegetation restoration in ecologically vulnerable areas, such as the Loess Plateau.