No easy fix for belief bias during syllogistic reasoning?

被引:4
|
作者
Boissin, Esther [1 ,4 ,5 ]
Caparos, Serge [2 ,3 ]
De Neys, Wim [1 ]
机构
[1] Univ Paris Cite, LaPsyDE, CNRS, Paris, France
[2] Univ Paris 08, DysCo Lab, St Denis, France
[3] Inst Univ France, Paris, France
[4] CNRS, LaPsyDE, 46 Rue St Jacques, F-75005 Paris, France
[5] Univ Paris Cite, Sorbonne Labo Binet A, 46 Rue St Jacques, F-75005 Paris, France
关键词
Reasoning; heuristics & biases; de-biasing; intuition; syllogistic reasoning; CONFLICT DETECTION; THINK;
D O I
10.1080/20445911.2023.2181734
中图分类号
B84 [心理学];
学科分类号
04 ; 0402 ;
摘要
Although erroneous intuitions often lead human thinking astray, recent studies suggest that single-shot interventions in which the underlying problem logic is clarified can easily remediate this bias. Because previous work typically focused on numerical problems, we tested here the generalizability to the infamous non-numerical belief bias during syllogistic reasoning. Unfortunately, results of 3 studies show that the effect is less clear. Although we succeeded in boosting performance for a minority of reasoners, reasoners who remained biased also tended to show a worse performance after training. We conclude that more work is needed to optimise the single-shot "easy fix" intervention approach to remediate belief bias during syllogistic reasoning.
引用
收藏
页码:401 / 421
页数:21
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [41] DEVELOPMENT OF SYLLOGISTIC REASONING
    BARA, BG
    BUCCIARELLI, M
    JOHNSONLAIRD, PN
    AMERICAN JOURNAL OF PSYCHOLOGY, 1995, 108 (02): : 157 - 193
  • [42] Belief bias across two domains of reasoning
    Martin, Nadia
    Fugelsang, Jonathan
    CANADIAN JOURNAL OF EXPERIMENTAL PSYCHOLOGY-REVUE CANADIENNE DE PSYCHOLOGIE EXPERIMENTALE, 2007, 61 (04): : 355 - 355
  • [43] Belief bias effect in reasoning of future teachers
    Cavojova, Vladimira
    INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE ON NEW HORIZONS IN EDUCATION, INTE 2014, 2015, 174 : 2211 - 2218
  • [44] BELIEVABILITY AND SYLLOGISTIC REASONING
    OAKHILL, J
    JOHNSONLAIRD, PN
    GARNHAM, A
    COGNITION, 1989, 31 (02) : 117 - 140
  • [45] Strategies in syllogistic reasoning
    Bucciarelli, M
    Johnson-Laird, PN
    COGNITIVE SCIENCE, 1999, 23 (03) : 247 - 303
  • [46] CHILDRENS SYLLOGISTIC REASONING
    JOHNSONLAIRD, PN
    OAKHILL, J
    BULL, D
    QUARTERLY JOURNAL OF EXPERIMENTAL PSYCHOLOGY SECTION A-HUMAN EXPERIMENTAL PSYCHOLOGY, 1986, 38 (01): : 35 - 58
  • [47] The effects of belief and logic in syllogistic reasoning: Evidence from an eye-tracking analysis
    Ball, LJ
    Quayle, JD
    PROCEEDINGS OF THE TWENTY FIRST ANNUAL CONFERENCE OF THE COGNITIVE SCIENCE SOCIETY, 1999, : 49 - 54
  • [48] Advanced Computing with Words Using Syllogistic Reasoning and Arithmetic Operations on Linguistic Belief Structures
    Rajati, Mohammad Reza
    Mendel, Jerry M.
    2013 IEEE INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE ON FUZZY SYSTEMS (FUZZ - IEEE 2013), 2013,
  • [49] The Influence of Activation Level on Belief Bias in Relational Reasoning
    Banks, Adrian P.
    COGNITIVE SCIENCE, 2013, 37 (03) : 544 - 577
  • [50] Belief bias is stronger when reasoning is more difficult
    Brisson, Janie
    de Chantal, Pier-Luc
    Forgues, Hugues Lortie
    Markovits, Henry
    THINKING & REASONING, 2014, 20 (03) : 385 - 403