Squamous cell carcinoma (SCC) of the nail unit is a rare malignant subungual tumor. There is often a delay in diagnosis and treatment it can be often misdiagnosed as chronic paronychia, onychomycosis, pyogenic granuloma, subungual wart, or glomus tumor. Here, we present a case of an elderly man who was brought to the patient department with a deformed appearance of the right fourth finger of his hand after 1 year. With a preceding history of trauma two sessions of excision of the finger nail showing onychomycosis, patient was admitted for further evaluation. Imaging in form of X-ray the hand and Magnetic resonance imaging of the finger showed bony destruction of middle and distal phalanges, thereby favoring fungal osteomyelitis. However, incisional biopsy from the nail unit revealed suspicious of SCC. A multimodal approach to the tumor is required; however, surgical excision is the definitive treatment.