Improving and comparing performance of machine learning classifiers optimized by swarm intelligent algorithms for code smell detection

In complex systems, the maintenance phase engenders the emergence of code smells due to incessant shifts in requirements and designs, stringent timelines, and the developer's relative inexperience. While not conventionally classified as errors, code smells inherently signify flawed design structures that lead to future bugs and errors. It increases the software budget and eventually makes the system hard to maintain or completely obsolete. To mitigate these challenges, practitioners must detect and refactor code smells. However, the theoretical interpretation of smell definitions and intelligent establishment of threshold values pose a significant conundrum. Supervised machine learning emerges as a potent strategy to address these problems and alleviate the dependence on expert intervention. The learning mechanism of these algorithms can be refined through data pre-processing and hyperparameter tuning. Selecting the best values for hyperparameters can be tedious and requires an expert. This study introduces an innovative paradigm that fuses twelve swarm-based, meta-heuristic algorithms with two machine learning classifiers, optimizing their hyperparameters, eliminating the need for an expert, and automating the entire code smell detection process. Through this synergistic approach, the highest post-optimization accuracy, precision, recall, F-measure, and ROC-AUC values are 99.09%, 99.20%, 99.09%, 98.06%, and 100%, respectively. The most remarkable upsurge is 35.9% in accuracy, 53.79% in precision, 35.90% in recall, 44.73% in F-measure, and 36.28% in ROC-AUC. Artificial Bee Colony, Grey Wolf, and Salp Swarm Optimizer are the top-performing swarm-intelligent algorithms. God and Data Class are the most readily detectable smells with optimized classifiers. Statistical tests underscore the profound impact of employing swarm-based algorithms to optimize machine learning classifiers, corroborated by statistical tests. This seamless integration enhances classifier performance, automates code smell detection, and offers a robust solution to a persistent software engineering challenge.