Impact of carboxylate ligation on the C-H activation reactivity of a non-heme Fe(IV)O complex: a computational investigation

A comprehensive DFT investigation has been presented to predict how a carboxylate-rich macrocycle would affect the reactivity of a non-heme Fe(IV)O complex towards C-H activation. The popular non-heme iron oxo complex [Fe-IV(O)(N4Py)](2+), (N4Py = N,N-(bis(2-pyridyl)methyl)N-bis(2-pyridylmethyl)amine) (1), has been selected here as the primary compound. It is transformed to the compound [Fe-IV(O)(Bu-n-P2DA)], where Bu-n-P2DA = N-(1 ',1 '-bis(2-pyridyl)pentyl)iminodiacetate (2) after the replacement of two pyridine donors of N4Py with carboxylate groups. Two other complexes, namely 3 and 4, have been predicted sequentially substituting nitrogen with the carboxylate groups. Ethylbenzene and dihydrotoluene were chosen as substrates. In terms of C-H activation reactivity, an interesting pattern emerges: as the carboxylate group becomes more equatorially enriched, the reactivity increases, following the trend 1 < 2 < 3 < 4. This also aligns with available experimental reports related to complexes 1 and 2. Fe(IV)O complexes exhibit two-state reactivity (triplet and quintet), whereas the quintet state is more favourable due to the stabilization of the transition states through exchange interactions involving a greater number of unpaired electrons. A detailed analysis of the factors influencing reactivity has been performed, including distortion energy (which decreases for the transition state with the addition of carboxylate groups), the triplet-quintet oxidant energy gap (which consistently decreases as carboxylate group enrichment increases), steric factors, and quantum mechanical tunneling. This investigation provides a detailed explanation of the observed outcomes and predicts the higher reactivity of carboxylate-enriched Fe(IV)O complexes. After potential experimental verification, this could lead to the development of new, optimal catalysts for C-H activation.