Belonging in the workplace: Methodology for fair and equitable data analysis

被引:0
|
作者
Carter, A. D. [1 ]
Richardson-Bryant, A. W. [1 ]
Da Silva, E. [1 ]
Mutilva, S. [2 ]
Melgar, C. [2 ]
Mohamed, H. [1 ]
Halbert, J. [2 ]
机构
[1] Adler Univ, Dept Ind & Org Psychol, Online Global Campus & Vancouver, Vancouver, BC, Canada
[2] Adler Univ, Dept Leadership & Appl Psychol, Online Campus, Chicago, IL USA
来源
CIM JOURNAL | 2024年 / 15卷 / 03期
关键词
Belonging; Employee retention; Equity; Governance; Intersectionality; Leadership; Mediation analysis; Mining; Organization; Statistical treatment; Survey data; Sustainability; analyse de m & eacute; diation; appartenance; direction; donn & eacute; es d'enqu & ecirc; te; durabilit & eacute; & eacute; quit & eacute; exploitation mini & egrave; re; gouvernance; intersectionnalit & eacute; la r & eacute; tention des employ & eacute; s; organisation; traitement statistique; INTERSECTIONALITY; DISCRIMINATION; MANAGEMENT; SENSE; WORK;
D O I
10.1080/19236026.2023.2267941
中图分类号
TF [冶金工业];
学科分类号
0806 ;
摘要
To remain globally competitive, the Canadian mining industry requires sustainability protocols to enhance the hiring and retention of diverse and underrepresented employees. Belonging in the workplace acts as a bridge, but literature demonstrates bias in current survey analysis practices that reinforces status quo and favors homogeneous groups. Using mediation analysis, this research investigated how an employee's intersections of identity (gender, ethnicity, and career level) influence belonging in the workplace perception. Data from 3,508 participants from 13 Toronto Stock Exchange listed companies were used to evaluate perceived organizational belonging through five validated indicators (comfort, connection, contribution, psychological safety, and well-being). Using multiplicative analysis, we explored how employees' intersecting identities change their perception of belonging in the workplace. Study results show clear direct and indirect effects when intersections of identity are accounted for. With the intersections of identity frequently misunderstood in survey analysis and the workplace, this research explores how status quo decisions lead to exclusion and turnover of underrepresented employees. Applying mediation analysis explains the variance in perception of belonging in the workplace and provides insight into the distortions of workplace experience while providing support for sustainability protocols. Pour rester comp & eacute;titive au niveau mondial, l'industrie mini & egrave;re canadienne a besoin de protocoles de durabilit & eacute; afin d'am & eacute;liorer l'embauche et le maintien en poste d'employ & eacute;s diversifi & eacute;s et sous-repr & eacute;sent & eacute;s. L'appartenance au milieu de travail sert de pont, mais la documentation d & eacute;montre que les pratiques actuelles d'analyse des sondages sont biais & eacute;es et qu'elles renforcent le statu quo et favorisent les groupes homog & egrave;nes. & Agrave; l'aide d'une analyse de m & eacute;diation, cette recherche a & eacute;tudi & eacute; comment les intersections de l'identit & eacute; d'un employ & eacute; (sexe, ethnicit & eacute; et niveau de carri & egrave;re) influencent la perception de l'appartenance au lieu de travail. Les donn & eacute;es de 3 508 participants de 13 entreprises cot & eacute;es & agrave; la Bourse de Toronto ont & eacute;t & eacute; utilis & eacute;es pour & eacute;valuer la perception de l'appartenance organisationnelle au moyen de cinq indicateurs valid & eacute;s (confort, connexion, contribution, s & eacute;curit & eacute; psychologique et bien-& ecirc;tre). & Agrave; l'aide d'une analyse multiplicative, nous avons explor & eacute; la fa & ccedil;on dont les identit & eacute;s crois & eacute;es des employ & eacute;s modifient leur perception de l'appartenance au lieu de travail. Les r & eacute;sultats de l'& eacute;tude montrent des effets directs et indirects clairs lorsque les croisements d'identit & eacute;s sont pris en compte. Les intersections de l'identit & eacute; & eacute;tant souvent mal comprises dans l'analyse des enqu & ecirc;tes et sur le lieu de travail, cette recherche explore la mani & egrave;re dont les d & eacute;cisions de statu quo conduisent & agrave; l'exclusion et & agrave; la rotation des travailleurs sous-repr & eacute;sent & eacute;s. L'exclusion et la rotation des employ & eacute;s sous-repr & eacute;sent & eacute;s. L'application de l'analyse de la m & eacute;diation explique la variance de la perception de l'appartenance sur le lieu de travail et donne un aper & ccedil;u des distorsions de l'exp & eacute;rience sur le lieu de travail, tout en apportant un soutien aux protocoles de durabilit & eacute;.
引用
收藏
页码:117 / 135
页数:19
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [41] Existence of a simple and equitable fair division: A short proof
    Cheze, Guillaume
    MATHEMATICAL SOCIAL SCIENCES, 2017, 87 : 92 - 93
  • [42] A Generalized Methodology for Data Analysis
    Angelov, Plamen P.
    Gu, Xiaowei
    Principe, Jose C.
    IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON CYBERNETICS, 2018, 48 (10) : 2981 - 2993
  • [43] Methodology of data analysis in sociology
    Butenko, IA
    SOTSIOLOGICHESKIE ISSLEDOVANIYA, 1999, (06): : 150 - 151
  • [45] Equitable resource allocation for municipal safety: A data envelopment analysis
    Ryan, Alyssa
    Barchers, Camille
    Christofa, Eleni
    Knodler, Michael
    TRANSPORTATION RESEARCH PART D-TRANSPORT AND ENVIRONMENT, 2021, 97
  • [46] Fair and Equitable Treatment and Human Rights: A Moral and Legal Reconciliation
    Ratner, Steven R.
    JOURNAL OF INTERNATIONAL ECONOMIC LAW, 2022, 25 (04) : 568 - 591
  • [47] Equitable Deep Learning for Glaucoma Screening with Fair Identity Normalization
    Wang, Mengyu
    Luo, Yan
    Tian, Yu
    Shen, Lucy Q.
    Elze, Tobias
    Zebardast, Nazlee
    Boland, Michael V.
    Friedman, David S.
    Pasquale, Louis R.
    Shi, Min
    INVESTIGATIVE OPHTHALMOLOGY & VISUAL SCIENCE, 2024, 65 (07)
  • [48] Fair Share: Equitable Distribution of Deep Sea Mining Proceeds
    Willaert, Klaas
    INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF MARINE AND COASTAL LAW, 2022, 37 (01):
  • [49] Optimal Incentive Mechanisms for Fair and Equitable Rewards in PoS Blockchains
    Sahin, Hadi
    Akkaya, Kemal
    Ganapati, Sukumar
    2022 IEEE INTERNATIONAL PERFORMANCE, COMPUTING, AND COMMUNICATIONS CONFERENCE, IPCCC, 2022,
  • [50] Fair and efficient resource allocation - Bicriteria models for equitable optimization
    Ogryczak, Wlodzimierz
    ICINCO 2008: PROCEEDINGS OF THE FIFTH INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE ON INFORMATICS IN CONTROL, AUTOMATION AND ROBOTICS, VOL ICSO: INTELLIGENT CONTROL SYSTEMS AND OPTIMIZATION, 2008, : 149 - 156